Categories
Blog Post

Why Andy is right to focus on council building and social rent housing

The stated intention of Andy Burnham to get the largest building of council housing at social rents since the post war period is a positive and welcome commitment that could progress the Labour policy to build 1.5 million homes.

Last year’s Comprehensive Spending Review put much more money into building social housing than for many years and also gave opportunities for borrowing from the Public Works Loan Board at lower rates of interest.

However, it was not surprising that a hoped for a kickstart to getting the new homes built has been painfully slow. A firmer focus on building council social housing, with money to back it up, will make a real difference, but as well as putting in more grant investment a few other things need to be done.

Firstly, it has to be recognised that building housing is very different to other government expenditure. It is still seen as part of public debt under the Public Sector Net Financial Liabilities (PSNFL) measure – as if it is like education or the health service – but this is wrong because there is a return on investment in housing. Yes, it is a more gradual return if it is at social rent, but if it is properly built and well managed, there is a return and in reality, it does not take that much longer to get that return if it is social rent housing as opposed to higher rent forms.

The irony is that spending by Housing Associations on housing is not part of the PSNFL, but it is for councils, and fundamentally there is no real difference. It is a quirk of public accounting that if tweaked can open up great housing possibilities. Just remove this false accounting system and the criticism of, “But Andy, where is the money coming from?” disappears.

The second thing is to take another lesson from the post-war Labour Government and reduce further and more substantially the interest rates from the Public Works Loan Board – if it is for social rent housing. This will provide a further kick-start that councils can benefit from.

The third thing to recognise – and Andy already mentioned that he understands this – is that housebuilding at social rent levels will bring great savings on the welfare bill. The saving takes time to filter through, but housing at social council rents will save billions on housing benefit – and will be better for people struggling to survive on market rents and on so-called ‘Affordable Rents’ that can be 80% of market rents. The housing benefit cost is set to be around £34 billion this year. The benefits bill can be reduced substantially while making people happier and leaving more money in their pockets.

The other point that should not be forgotten is that we need to start building the family housing that people need. Too often, targets are met by building one- and two-bedroom housing and ignoring the need for family housing.

Finally, there has to be a new focus on small and medium size companies filling the gaps in housebuilding. There has been too much reliance on big builders, and they can use that to make excess profits and be picky about what they do and do not do. Along with this, there needs to be a strengthening of the supply chain, including with better apprenticeship schemes and help and encouragement for the smaller companies to be part of such schemes.

In all these ways, Andy’s commitment to council housing can transform the country across a wide range of fronts, from health and education to economic growth.

Would you like to write for Red Brick? Email rose.grayston@gmail.com to pitch your piece (c.600-900 words)

Categories
Blog Post

Lessons from our history: Britain must build places, not units

There is a growing consensus that something has fundamentally gone wrong at all levels with housing in Britain.  We often search for new approaches and policies to meet society’s needs when in fact we should instead look at our history for the solutions.

The Labour Government understands that the housing market is dysfunctional, that housing supply for decades has been inadequate and is rightly appalled at inheriting a situation where there are over 300,000 people, including more than 170,000 children, in all forms of temporary accommodation.  In this context, the response to set an ambitious target of 1.5 million new homes over 5 years is appropriate.  I am, however, concerned that even with a record £39 billion committed to the affordable housing programme, this will not produce anywhere near enough truly affordable homes, and in particular, the right kind of social rent homes to meet the crushing levels of housing need.

My worry is that in a drive to hit house building targets we lose sight of something of enormous importance, and that is the need to create communities where people want to live and want to put down roots.

This is where looking at our history becomes so important. During the inter-war years of the early twentieth century, and then in the post second world war period, pioneering planners and local authorities in Britain, despite the most challenging of circumstances, created garden cities and new towns that have stood the test of time.

The Dagenham and Rainham constituency that I represent contains much of the Becontree housing estate started in the 1920s. The planners of the London County Council had the foresight to adopt much of the thinking that inspired the earlier garden city movement. Building 2, 3 and 4 bedroom houses with gardens, in an area where parks and other green public spaces were created, gave life changing conditions for families moving from slum tenement blocks in east London.  

The housing supply of the last decade or two has been driven, predominately, by the targeting of numbers and by building viability arguments from developers. This has resulted in the over-supply of 1-bedroom flats and a nearly complete absence of 4-bedroom properties.

Instead, we must treat building as a part of place making. We must consider nurturing sustainable communities which are more balanced, incorporating the essential social and transport infrastructure needed to support new and existing communities.

That would also mean changing the housing mix in terms of tenure and house sizes and to build sufficient numbers of homes suitable for families. It would mean building specific accommodation for elderly people designed to promote and extend independent living. This would in fact save revenue spending on social care and demands on health services.

I strongly suspect that this model of housing development would not just have greater longevity than the high-rise apartment block estates do, but would engender much higher levels of wellbeing, with all of the positive social and health outcome benefits that flow from it.

It would also not surprise me if this approach reduces opposition from existing communities to new housing schemes.  This would also save planning expenses and time, and give a greater feeling of ownership and of being done by, rather than done to.

As a nation we did this before and did so in even more financially challenging times. Not only that, but those places and homes have stood the test of time.

Building for the future means planning neighbourhoods around the flow of life. From having the infrastructure to provide the best start in life, affordable first homes, places to work and socialise, family sized homes for social rent where people can put down roots, to sheltered options where people can grow old in the community they call home.

Only a legacy plan will help us surmount the housing crisis, not a dash for units.

Would you like to write for Red Brick? Email rose.grayston@gmail.com to pitch your piece (c.600-900 words)