Categories
Blog Post

Public land for public good: making room for community-led housing

Housing is top of the agenda again and so much of Andy Burnham’s speech to Labour Party Conference was music to my ears. Getting councils building again, eradicating rough sleeping, a Prime Minister who recognises how having a decent house unlocked opportunities for his own family. Far too often, the debate around housing has been reduced to bricks and mortar. How many units can we deliver and how quickly? But we mustn’t lose sight of the end goal – a home where people can live safe and securely, and communities in which people are supported to thrive.

More than bricks and mortar

During my time as a local councillor and Cabinet Member for New Homes in Southwark, I saw some fantastic examples of people living together in community. On existing council estates where Tenants & Residents’ Associations were not only providing excellent representation on issues like housing repairs, but were running community centres, bringing people together for festivals, and greening their estates. On the Rockingham Estate in South London, part of the ward that I represented, volunteers have turned a corner of SE1 (central London) into a biodiversity haven, designated as a Site of Importance for Nature Conservation and even growing bananas together!

One new development in Bermondsey which has been intentionally designed to inspire community and combat loneliness is the award-winning Appleby Blue Almshouse, run by the United St Saviour’s Charity. It’s not just the oak panelling that makes it special, but the inclusion of residential walkways, an enormous space which often hosts lunches and other events, a community kitchen and beautiful internal courtyard. The research team there have published evidence showing that living in an almshouse can boost life expectancy by 2.5 years.

At a time of deepening polarisation and immense housing need, the design of homes and communities matters more than ever and where the public sector owns land, there are the most options. Whether it’s the new council housing that Andy Burnham is promising, or new dedicated homes for keyworkers, public land can be used to deliver public good. Call that Manchesterism if you like but it’s also what we did in Southwark to deliver Appleby Blue. A charity-led scheme but built on the site of a disused care home owned by Southwark. There is so much pressure on hard-pressed local authorities to dispose of their land on the private market for a capital receipt, but in doing so, this kind of creativity and public good is what you forgo.

Speaking at a Co-operative Party event earlier this year launching their pamphlet, Yes in My Backyard, Angela Rayner threw her weight behind community-led housing and a new co-operative housing tenure. This sector is one which I have been increasingly interested in, and it remains relatively small in the UK compared with our European neighbours. New initiatives like Collective Ownership have the potential to scale up community-led acquisitions, but some schemes also need public land and a bit of state support to get off the ground.

Following the successful delivery of Community Land Trusts (CLTs) in Tower Hamlets and Lewisham, I was working as a Cabinet Member to deliver Southwark’s first CLT in Peckham on council-owned land. This has been progressing slowly, but now, like many other schemes which have a similar model of tenure (discounted sales values which are permanently affordable, linked in perpetuity to average local incomes), there is no grant funding available to make it happen in this form. This model has been excluded from the £39bn Social & Affordable Homes Programme and as yet no replacement or amended Community Housing Fund has been agreed.

Ambition needs funding and political backing

There are challenges across the country for co-operative and community led housing which demonstrate the need for much stronger political support. The immensely saddening dispute between GreenSquare Accord Housing Association and Stirchley Cooperative Development highlights the risks around private partnership, even in this case with a not-for-profit. Another London CLT scheme, which would have provided 41 affordable homes on Cable Street in East London, is now at risk due to a change of view from Transport for London, who own the land. In Yorkshire and the North-East, the will is certainly there and a number of community organisations have recently come together to launch The Northern Way, building on their years of experience bringing empty homes back into use, supporting vulnerable people back into employment and revitalising neighbourhoods that have often felt neglected. But without anything akin to the former Empty Homes Community Grants Programme, the resources just aren’t there to deliver at scale, despite the model ticking multiple boxes: social housing, employment and skills, retrofit, and neighbourhood renewal.

Harnessing the enthusiasm, experience and existing pipeline of these community-led organisations would be a quick win for the new administration, led by our first ever Labour & Cooperative Prime Minister. It is immensely encouraging that housing is such a significant priority for Andy Burnham. His leadership across Greater Manchester on initiatives like Housing First and bringing Empty Homes back into use is now being translated into national policy. That points the way to a more rounded housing policy, focused on using public land and investment. My hope is that the potential for partnering with community groups is now fully realised and integral to this renewed vision to deliver on decent homes and supportive communities for all.

Helen Dennis is a former councillor and Southwark Council Cabinet Member for New Homes and Sustainable Development. She is currently an Associate Fellow at the New Economics Foundation and a board member of London Community Land Trust. She writes here in a personal capacity.

Would you like to write for Red Brick? Email rose.grayston@gmail.com to pitch your piece (c.600-1,200 words)

Categories
Blog Post

What devolution can do for council housebuilding

The Prime Minister has said he wants to achieve “the biggest council housebuilding programme since the post-war period”. In doing so, he has leant into a safe rhetorical space, while also giving himself a big practical challenge. Councils generally don’t build much anymore, and to achieve his goal, Burnham must find a way to resuscitate them.

Greater devolution to mayors can help him do this. Let me explain.

Aiming for a return to large-scale council housebuilding has a clear rationale: Councils have responsibility for addressing homelessness, they have planning and compulsory purchase powers which should enable their building programmes, and they are more locally and politically accountable than housing associations.

But an immediate return to the era of municipal dreams is not possible.

In the post-war period, local authorities had a level of fiscal and programme-level autonomy that would seem almost unlimited to 21st century local authorities. Firstly, there was no hard limit on capital expenditure. If schemes met basic size and fittings standards and could be funded at the ‘yardstick’ grant rate, councils could draw down funding from central government. Local authorities also had much greater freedom to set their own rents, they could sell (or not sell) property they owned when they wanted to, and they also often bought land and built outside of their own local boundaries.

This period came to an end with the 1976 IMF bailout imposing hard departmental capital spending controls, subsequent limits to local government borrowing, and the imposition of the Right to Buy. But it is important to remember that it was local freedoms and certainty, rather than the policies which ended them, that defined the post-war period.  

Today, hard budget constraints from central government continue to define what is possible, and will continue to do so, even if the size of the pot allocated to public housebuilding increases. Councils’ role is residualised, with half not owning any of their own stock and local authorities building only 9 per cent of new social and affordable homes outside London in the last 3 years.

Access to grant funding, administered by Homes England, is set up with the assumption that large housing associations will lead on housebuilding For councils and smaller housing associations, an uncertain system of continuous, competitive bidding makes it difficult to develop consistent development pipelines and grow their operations.

Undoing the difference between these two worlds cannot be done in one go. But the new Government can seek to emulate at least two key features of the post-war regime: firstly, a consistent funding stream councils can draw on, and secondly, local policy autonomy.

Devolution of responsibility for social and affordable housing from MHCLG and Homes England to mayors could help do this.

Firstly, mayors could take on Homes England’s role as distributors of grant funding. Rather than requiring councils to bid for funding scheme by scheme, mayors could agree long-term grant allocations from which councils could draw down. This would give councils the confidence to acquire land, plan development and rebuild the capacity needed to deliver housing consistently, while allowing them to respond to delays and changing costs.

London provides a partial example of how this could work. Five-year funding agreements between the Mayor and boroughs have helped some councils develop the largest housebuilding programmes in the country. But the GLA remains constrained by the amount, timing and conditions of funding it receives from central government.

Devolution therefore needs to be fiscal. Rather than simply asking mayors to distribute centrally determined pots, they should retain set shares of taxes raised locally. Initial funding settlements would need to be set such that funding matched places’ differing levels of need, but these would evolve only periodically and slowly, such is the stickiness of housing problems. This would provide a more stable funding base than grant regimes which can change at any budget or spending review, thus enabling mayors to support councils to plan and develop their housebuilding programmes.

This support from mayors should then come with greater policy autonomy for local authorities, including on the mix of home sizes in developments and the shares of tenures in any given development, so they can respond to local needs and local viability challenges.

Finally, just as local authorities used to respond to land constraints by building beyond their own boundaries (and, in London, rehousing residents in London County Council or Greater London Council-led schemes) mayors in cities today could help manage issues across constituent authorities. Many urban authorities face higher demand than they can build for, and with waiting lists managed council-by-council, many households are left with almost no hope of ever securing a council home.

Mayors could help untangle this by establishing schemes that enable households to move to faster-building authorities, if those households wished to prioritise speed of rehousing over stay in the immediate area.

Now devolution as described couldn’t happen in all places all at once. It could be fast tracked in established mayoralties, such as Greater Manchester and West Yorkshire, while places still waiting for mayors could prepare to take on new responsibilities over time.

Devolution also isn’t a panacea, or the only thing needed to boost council housebuilding. The overall scale of grant funding will continue to set the upper bound for how much gets built. A more permissive planning system, reduced build costs, and clarity on when new compulsory purchase powers can be used to reduce land costs, are all also needed if that maximum is to be reached.

But especially in cities, where multiple councils complicate the management of housing need, mayors can help councils do more. The Prime Minister cannot easily recreate the world in which councils could draw on as much funding as they liked, but using mayors he can establish a system that restores some of that world’s long-term certainty, local autonomy and local responsibility.

Would you like to write for Red Brick? Email rose.grayston@gmail.com to pitch your piece (c.600-1200 words)

Categories
Blog Post

A secure home shouldn’t depend on owning one

Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s first conference as Labour leader opened with a promise to young people locked out of the housing market: a new-build home for just a 2.5% deposit, supported by a government-backed equity loan of up to 20% of the property’s value. Your First Home is a more targeted Help to Buy, aimed at first-time buyers who don’t have help with a deposit from the ‘Bank of Mum and Dad’. In many ways, this is an admirable goal, especially given that the National Audit Office found that 3 in 5 of those who accessed the previous version of the scheme could have bought the same home without it.

Demand-side fixes for structural problems in the housing market fundamentally mean public money boosts developer profits by inflating demand for new homes and subsequently the cost that can be charged for each unit. But beyond this, Your First Home raises bigger questions about progressive approaches to housing.

A generation of people are struggling to find secure, affordable housing. Private rental unaffordability is now a national phenomenon, with rents in every region growing between 6% and 9% per year and 1 in 5 private renters reporting cutting back on food to afford housing costs. The average age of renters is increasing, with the numbers of households aged over 55 in the private rental sector growing by 70% over the last decade. The average age of first-time homeowners is also increasing across the country, rising to 34 years old.

The aspiration of homeownership is not one that should be dismissed. For millions of people, the dream of owning a home is about being free from the anxiety of eviction, or an unaffordable rent increase that tacitly serves as one; it’s about painting walls and making a house a home; about staying close to community, or near their childrens’ school. Ultimately, it’s about security, dignity and control. But why is homeownership the primary route to access these?

A more ambitious vision of housing security would expand people’s choices and control over their homes, rather than making it easier for a fortunate minority to climb the property ladder. The Government’s commitment to a council housing revolution is one way to do this.

For decades, millions of people found security and affordability in council homes. Not only is it a more affordable tenure type, but it’s an explicit form of long-term housing that enables people to put down roots. At its peak in the 1950s, Britain was building more than 200,000 council homes a year, a scale the market has never matched, and to higher standards than private builders were required to meet. By 1979, almost a third of households rented from their council.

Right to Buy turned this collective good into a private asset. Since 1980, around two million council homes have been sold off, with 14,275 sold under Right to Buy during 2025–26 – a 90% increase on the previous year. More than 40% of these former council homes are now owned by private landlords. Research by Common Wealth found that Right to Buy has cost the taxpayer £200bn, and councils are increasingly buying-back homes sold off under Right to Buy at inflated costs. In particularly egregious examples, council houses sold off under Right to Buy are being rented back to local authorities as Temporary Accommodation (TA) just months later. In Havering, a home sold for £102,000 has cost the council £350,000 renting it back as TA; in Newham, a home sold for £77,300, has seen the council pay £200,000 in rent. Given that local authority spending on TA has doubled over the last five years to a record £2.9bn, the problem isn’t that the state is failing to spend on housing. It’s that it’s spending a fortune on the most expensive, least secure version of it – paying exorbitant rents to private landlords, rather than building homes that will still house families in decades to come.

Indeed, that the people living in council homes can stay in them for as long as needed, regardless of whether income rises or falls, has always been a central part of the council house offer. The growing argument that social housing subsidises the ‘wrong’ people, as The Economist put it this summer, is not only wrong, but has been tried before. In 2016, a proposal to make higher earning social housing tenants pay market rents to stay in their homes was dropped before taking effect. It deserved to be. Treating council and social housing as a temporary safety net is precisely what residualised the tenure from a mainstream option for a broad mix of people to a last resort concentrated on the poorest and most vulnerable, while also weakening the public support needed to build more.

Burnham has said housing should be treated as an essential service, not a market of winners and losers. Your First Home, however well targeted, helps a few more people become winners. If the Government is serious about ending forty years of neoliberalism, then the biggest council housebuilding programme since the post-war era is a worthy place to start. But it should be equally serious about what made those homes worth building: yes, lower rents, but also the promise that you could stay. Security, dignity and control over your home shouldn’t depend on whether you can raise a deposit, and the true test of a progressive housing policy shouldn’t be how many people it helps onto the ladder, but how many it gives a secure place to call home.

Would you like to write for Red Brick? Email rose.grayston@gmail.com to pitch your piece (c.600-1200 words)

Categories
Blog Post

Who is devolution really giving power to?

We have entered a new era in British governance, with devolution moving from a long-term ambition to the defining mission of government.

The promise is simple. Re-wire the state and move power away from Westminster and into the hands of regional leaders, bringing decision-making closer to the communities it affects.

But if power is moving closer to communities, who is it actually being devolved to?

The lessons we can’t afford to forget

For more than 35 years, Tpas has championed one simple principle – that housing works better when the residents affected by decisions help shape them. That belief has guided our work with residents, landlords, regulators and government, and it has helped drive significant change across the housing sector.

Grenfell forced the industry to confront an uncomfortable reality, when residents aren’t heard, the consequences can be devastating.

The reforms that followed, including stronger Consumer Standards, Tenant Satisfaction Measures, Awaab’s Law and greater transparency and accountability, recognised a simple truth: lived experience is not an optional extra. It is fundamental to good governance.

Over the coming months and years, we can expect to see powers over housing and communities increasingly move into combined authorities and local government.

This is welcome news, but there is a real risk that community voices cannot keep pace. Too often, engagement stops at the landlord level while the biggest decisions about investment, regeneration and place are made elsewhere.

We cannot afford to create a new generation of institutions that are any further removed from the people they serve than the ones they replace.

The next challenge for devolution

Our new policy paper, From Devolution to Participation, argues that resident participation must become part of the foundations of England’s devolved housing system, rather than an afterthought once decisions have already been made.

The report is not calling for more consultation for consultation’s sake. It sets out practical ways to give residents meaningful influence over the decisions being made at regional level.

That means creating resident advisory structures with a direct route into Combined Authority housing teams; ensuring evidence from tenant scrutiny, complaints and Tenant Satisfaction Measures shapes regional strategy and investment; supporting tenant-led organisations to participate on an equal footing; and requiring decision-makers to show residents what changed as a result of their involvement.

A once-in-a-generation opportunity

None of this requires starting from scratch. Nor will it be expensive. The foundations are already in place. The housing sector already has decades of experience, evidence and established structures to draw on.

We have seen from areas where devolution is already well established, such as the West Midlands Combined Authority and via the Good Landlord Charter in Greater Manchester, mayors and leaders are taking tenant voice seriously.

The task now is to formalise approaches and connect  expertise on tenant engagement to more regional bodies making increasingly significant decisions about homes, investment and place.

Every day, tenants contribute insight through panels, complaints and local forums. The challenge is not necessarily about listening, it is about acting on those voices so they influence the strategic decisions shaping housing investment that will be led by mayors.

If this Government is serious about democratic renewal, housing has the opportunity to become the blueprint for how communities shape regional government.

The political foundations are now in place. Andy Burnham has spoken about moving power closer to people, while Angela Rayner has long championed stronger communities and greater local influence.

How can we judge success?

As the Government begins the process of redesigning how England is governed, it has a unique opportunity to ensure community participation is built into that new system from the very beginning.

The success of devolution won’t be measured by how many powers leave Westminster.

Instead, it will be measured by whether the people those powers are meant to serve have a genuine seat at the table.

The housing sector has already learned, through both success and tragic experience, that better decisions are made when residents are listened to. Let’s not build a new system of regional government only to repeat the mistakes of the old one.

There will be plenty of people who are asking who devolution is really giving power to. The answer should be simple – the people whose lives those decisions shape every day.

If power is moving out of Westminster, resident voice must move with it.

Would you like to write for Red Brick? Email rose.grayston@gmail.com to pitch your piece (c.600-900 words)

Categories
Blog Post

Why Andy is right to focus on council building and social rent housing

The stated intention of Andy Burnham to get the largest building of council housing at social rents since the post war period is a positive and welcome commitment that could progress the Labour policy to build 1.5 million homes.

Last year’s Comprehensive Spending Review put much more money into building social housing than for many years and also gave opportunities for borrowing from the Public Works Loan Board at lower rates of interest.

However, it was not surprising that a hoped for a kickstart to getting the new homes built has been painfully slow. A firmer focus on building council social housing, with money to back it up, will make a real difference, but as well as putting in more grant investment a few other things need to be done.

Firstly, it has to be recognised that building housing is very different to other government expenditure. It is still seen as part of public debt under the Public Sector Net Financial Liabilities (PSNFL) measure – as if it is like education or the health service – but this is wrong because there is a return on investment in housing. Yes, it is a more gradual return if it is at social rent, but if it is properly built and well managed, there is a return and in reality, it does not take that much longer to get that return if it is social rent housing as opposed to higher rent forms.

The irony is that spending by Housing Associations on housing is not part of the PSNFL, but it is for councils, and fundamentally there is no real difference. It is a quirk of public accounting that if tweaked can open up great housing possibilities. Just remove this false accounting system and the criticism of, “But Andy, where is the money coming from?” disappears.

The second thing is to take another lesson from the post-war Labour Government and reduce further and more substantially the interest rates from the Public Works Loan Board – if it is for social rent housing. This will provide a further kick-start that councils can benefit from.

The third thing to recognise – and Andy already mentioned that he understands this – is that housebuilding at social rent levels will bring great savings on the welfare bill. The saving takes time to filter through, but housing at social council rents will save billions on housing benefit – and will be better for people struggling to survive on market rents and on so-called ‘Affordable Rents’ that can be 80% of market rents. The housing benefit cost is set to be around £34 billion this year. The benefits bill can be reduced substantially while making people happier and leaving more money in their pockets.

The other point that should not be forgotten is that we need to start building the family housing that people need. Too often, targets are met by building one- and two-bedroom housing and ignoring the need for family housing.

Finally, there has to be a new focus on small and medium size companies filling the gaps in housebuilding. There has been too much reliance on big builders, and they can use that to make excess profits and be picky about what they do and do not do. Along with this, there needs to be a strengthening of the supply chain, including with better apprenticeship schemes and help and encouragement for the smaller companies to be part of such schemes.

In all these ways, Andy’s commitment to council housing can transform the country across a wide range of fronts, from health and education to economic growth.

Would you like to write for Red Brick? Email rose.grayston@gmail.com to pitch your piece (c.600-900 words)

Categories
Blog Post

Social rent council housing should be the Government’s first housing priority

The first tranche of funding for the Government’s Social & Affordable Homes Programme (SAHP) has been announced. Of 73,617 “affordable homes” to be built by “Strategic Partners”, funded by the programme, only 3.8% are to be built by councils.

On X, the Labour Party said that “Labour is funding more than 70,000 new homes across England, putting councils at the heart of house building”. Another post said, “This is the biggest council house building revival in decades.” In his first speech in Parliament Andy Burnham referred to “the biggest council house building programme since the post-war period”. What seems clear to us at the Labour Campaign for Council Housing is that this aspiration on council housing cannot possibly be achieved by the SAHP as currently constituted.

The stark reality is this:

  • £9.58 billion (outside of London) is being given to 33 “Strategic Partners” for multi-year programmes up to 2039;
  • Just three of them are councils (Cambridge, Eastleigh and Newcastle), with a combined funding of £392.2 million, supporting 2,811 homes;
  • The other 30 “Strategic Partners” are Housing Associations, save for two ‘for profit registered providers’, Sage and Park Properties Housing Association, and the large volume builder Vistry;
  • Sage and Vistry will receive almost as much as the councils combined; £350 million each.

Given that only 2,811 of the 73,617 homes will be built by councils, this cannot possibly represent “putting councils at the heart of house building”. Nor can it be described as “the biggest council house building revival in decades”.

The Government has said that “future stages of the programme will be tilted more towards councils”. Yet there is, currently, no funding ring-fenced for councils. They have to bid in the “Continuous Market Engagement” process, competing for grant with Housing Associations, “for profit registered providers”, developers and builders.

In London the funding is under the control of the Mayor rather than Homes England. Tom Copley, Deputy Mayor for Housing and Residential Development, announced that “60% of the funding from the first round of the mayor’s new SAHP will go to London boroughs to deliver even more new council homes.” Even so, if 60% was applied nationally, it would still only equate to 10,800 council homes a year. Demolitions and Right to Buy sales will reduce the net number. (Red Brick editor note: The Government is currently progressing reforms to restrict the Right to Buy through the Social Housing Bill ).

SAHP: “a flawed programme”

For us at the Labour Campaign for Council Housing, it was clear when it was first announced that the SAHP was “a flawed programme which would not solve the housing crisis”. The £39 billion pledged over a decade was never going to be sufficient. The 300,000 “affordable homes” it will fund equates to an average of 30,000 a year. Of those, 18,000 will be social rent homes, comprising just 6% of the Government’s annual target for overall housing supply. In no sense can this be described as ‘historic’.

There have only been six years in England when 300,000 or more homes have been built. In those, council housing made up an average of 41%; 135,000 a year.

On the last two occasions when Labour conferences have discussed housing, in 2019 and 2021, overwhelmingly the delegates voted for a Labour government to fund 150,000 social rent homes a year, including 100,000 council homes. Shelter and other organisations have said that as an absolute minimum 90,000 social rent homes a year are necessary. This would require far more funding than £39 billion.

The SAHP average grant is around £130,000 per unit (£39 billion for 300,000 homes). In its recent report for Shelter, Savills estimated an average grant per social rent unit of £177,000. That would add up to £15.9 billion a year; £159 billion for a decade. The Centre for Cities estimated that £16.6 billion a year would be needed to replicate the level of council house building from 1956 to 1979.

Is this unrealistic? No. We should remember that the Attlee Government, despite facing far worse economic circumstances than we do today (the debt to GDP ratio was 250%, compared to under 100% today), funded around 800,000 council homes. It is a question of priorities.

Investment today saves money in the future. Investment in social rent council homes will save money on the housing benefit bill by taking households out of the expensive private rental sector. It will save money for the NHS by taking households out of homes which will ruin their health. It will save councils the exorbitant cost of Temporary Accommodation.

“Affordable housing”

The scale of funding isn’t the only issue, though. The Government has kept the Tory definition of “Affordable Housing”. For instance, “Affordable Rent”, an austerity measure, was introduced by the Coalition Government to facilitate a 60% cut in grant funding. At up to 80% of market rents, it is unaffordable for many. It is £60 a week more than social rent in England, £90 a week in London. As well as impoverishing tenants, it simply drives up the housing benefit bill. Why does the Government propose to continue funding it through SAHP?

If the record numbers of 135,580 households in Temporary Accommodation and 1.3 million households on the social housing waiting lists are to be driven down, the Government needs to make social rent council housing its first priority, on at least the scale that Shelter has called for. If the gulf between the Government’s rhetoric and the actual content of its housing programme is not closed, there will be a political price to be paid.

Andy Burnham, whilst Mayor of Manchester, was right when he said, “The Government should make building hundreds of thousands of council homes its defining purpose. No other policy, achievable within a Parliament, would have greater social and economic benefits.”

That requires significantly more funding and the abandonment of the Tory definition of “Affordable Housing” (see our Letter to Angela Rayner). All the funding should go to social rent homes, the only genuinely affordable tenure for tenants. The Government cannot fend off the threat of a very right wing government, whatever its composition, without beginning to resolve the housing crisis. Council housing remains the key to that.

Martin Wicks

Labour Campaign for Council Housing

Details of membership and affiliation to the campaign can be found here.

Postscript

The 2026 Labour Party Conference voted through a UNITE resolution, as part of a composite motion. The conference voted for:

  • 90,000 social rent homes a year;
  • Ending Right to Buy;
  • Cancelling council housing debt;
  • A publicly funded retrofit programme.

Would you like to write for Red Brick? Email rose.grayston@gmail.com to pitch your piece (c.600-900 words)

Categories
Blog Post

More council homes, lower bills, stronger communities: Cambridge’s approach to building better

When people talk about sustainable housing, they generally focus on the physical structures. During my career as an architect, and now as part of Cambridge City Council’s Labour administration following the May 2026 elections, I have developed a broader vision of what counts as sustainable, looking beyond the building itself to ask how it works within the wider social setting, as a home and not just a house, and as part of a neighbourhood that meets people’s wider needs.

This means taking account of both the built and social environment, providing more than just basic housing, and understanding how a house contributes to the surrounding streetscape. When we build, we are not just assembling structures but weaving new threads into the existing community, and we need to make sure that everyone has the facilities and spaces they need to live sustainable, good lives.

So while my focus in Cambridge is on the quality of our council housing, our planning always takes account of that wider perspective, so that we build homes people want to live in, in attractive neighbourhoods with the amenities they need and good transport links.

We have built many council homes in Cambridge in the last eight years. Initially we had support from a £70 million funding package from our devolution deal with the Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Combined Authority, through which we committed to building 500 new council homes. In those early days, the Council’s focus was almost exclusively on quantity as we worked to hit our target. While we built to standards that were slightly better than national building regulations, the volume of delivery was our primary driver. We completed our 500th council home a year ahead of schedule, and have now built more than 850 new council homes.

We have evolved our approach in recent years. We still want to build at pace, but we also want to build to the highest possible quality. Investing in the fabric of the building was a strategic choice. Although it can increase upfront costs, it directly helps our tenants by bringing down utility bills and improving the comfort of their homes. This is only growing in importance as we experience the consequences of the climate emergency.

As the executive councillor for planning, I was proud to help bring forward our sustainable construction Supplementary Planning Document (SPD). Alongside this, we introduced a sustainable housing guide for our council house programme that aimed for certified Passivhaus standards. This was a highly significant moment, making it clear that we were aiming to build the most energy-efficient homes possible in Cambridge.

Yet, as any local authority knows, we have to constantly balance environmental ambitions with financial reality. We discovered that strict Passivhaus certification was incredibly expensive and financially demanding. Furthermore, Passivhaus design is heavily reliant on orienting and positioning buildings in particular ways. That’s not always possible when you are working with complex, irregular, or difficult urban “infill” sites – the sort we rely on to deliver the density of homes our city  desperately needs.  Recent schemes including Arbury Road and Kings Hedges in North Cambridge relied on the Cam Standard to make them viable.

We have not let this curtail our ambitions. In 2024 we created the “Cam Standard.” This bespoke standard acts as a robust baseline that maintains our commitment to energy efficiency and climate-change resilience, while offering the practical flexibility required for complex urban sites. It is a realistic, scalable stepping stone that ensures all our developments prioritise lowering energy use, with the explicit goal that all proposed council homes will target Net Zero Carbon by 2030.

And now we have the next stage to look forward to. as Cambridge is one of three councils to have secured long-term funding as a strategic partner under the government’s Social and Affordable Housing Programme (SAHP). This funding gives us the certainty we need to plan over a longer horizon and develop the pipeline for building another 1,400 high-quality council homes across our city, with the aim of ensuring 60% of those are available at social rent.

This funding is especially vital given the massive development pressures facing Cambridge. The government is planning major expansions, with a Development Corporation set to oversee significant growth. Our position as a Labour council is clear: we must protect the integrity of council house building and ensure there are genuinely affordable homes for our residents. Through our joint venture with The Hill Group, the Cambridge Investment Partnership (CIP), we aim for 50% of the homes built on our schemes across the city to be council homes. We will be engaging robustly with the incoming Development Corporation to ensure they recognise how vital this 50% target is in a city with such highly priced market homes.

Looking forward, all our new-build sites are fully electric and gas-free, and we want to provide on-site energy generation through PV. At the same time we’re looking at energy storage systems. While current lithium batteries raise environmental and safety concerns, the emergence of sodium batteries offers an exciting, sustainable alternative. Our ultimate goal is to provide “zero-utility-bill” council housing.

They are also designed as “Lifetime Homes” where a young couple can move in and expect to remain for their entire lives. All homes have private outside spaces and are wheelchair accessible, featuring wider doorways and, downstairs toilets. 5% of homes are also built with further adaptations for wheelchair users in mind.

Through our house building programme we have also built five new community centres, seven new parks and play areas, two pre-schools, one library and new shops. We have provided a further £12.2 million of funding to support local schools, parks, sports centres and the NHS.

By building high-quality, adaptable, and community-focused homes, I like to think that we also show private developers what is truly possible. In doing so, we are honouring the deep legacy of our movement. As the great Aneurin Bevan famously observed of post-war housing needs: “While we shall be judged for a year or two by the numbers of houses we built, we shall be judged in ten years by the type of houses we build.”

In Cambridge, as a regular top 10 council house builder, we have delivered on the numbers. Now, through the Cam Standard and our strategic partnership, we are ensuring that the houses we leave behind will stand as a proud legacy of sustainable, inclusive, and fair municipal design for generations to come.

Would you like to write for Red Brick? Email rose.grayston@gmail.com to pitch your piece (c.600-900 words)

Categories
Blog Post

Building the homes Brent needs: In conversation with Cllr Matt Kelcher

Red Brick: First, what does the housing crisis look like for people in Brent?

Matt Kelcher: We have many of the same challenges as other parts of London and the country: fundamentally, we need more housing of all different kinds.

We have more than 30,000 households on the housing waiting list, but it’s important to understand what that means. Only a proportion of those households are in priority need. People further down the list are extremely unlikely ever to receive a council home, however long they wait.

I think councils have to be honest about that. Being on a waiting list can give people the impression that if they sit tight for long enough, eventually they’ll get a home. The reality is that’s just not the way it works with the levels of social housing we have available today. The wait can be decades, and that uncertainty can affect decisions about new jobs, where children go to school and how people plan for the future. At Brent, we’ve set up our Find a place you can afford programme to give local people help now to find a private tenancy, rather than leaving them on a waiting list.

The housing crisis in Brent also goes well beyond the waiting list. We’re a young, incredibly diverse borough with strong family and community ties. A lot of people want to live in the borough where they grew up. They don’t want to move miles and miles away from their parents. But often there just aren’t the homes available for them here – whether that’s social housing, private rented housing, shared ownership or housing to buy.

You see young people with decent jobs who can’t move out of their childhood bedroom, young people who want to get on the housing ladder but can’t, and couples living in a one-bedroom flat who want to have children but can’t find somewhere bigger. If you don’t have somewhere secure that you can call your own, it has huge consequences for the way you live the rest of your life. It puts your life on hold. We want to free people from that by delivering secure homes of all types for everyone.

RB: Tell us about your approach to development. What can a Labour-run council actually do to shape development in a borough where much of the building is done by other organisations?

Brent has had a really good reputation for a long time of being somewhere that proactively welcomes development and the regeneration it brings. We are a rare example of a place in London that is managing to exceed our housing and planning targets.

I think being open and positive about development actually allows you to get more out of developers, not less. Development involves risk. If you’re going to spend months or years developing a scheme, but think there’s a significant chance the council will reject it at the end of the process, you either price that risk into the scheme or decide to invest somewhere else.

Brent has built a reputation as somewhere developers can have a constructive conversation with the council and get a fair hearing. That doesn’t mean saying “yes” to everything. It means being clear about what we want and working with developers to see whether they can deliver it.

That certainty makes Brent a more attractive place to invest. And if more developers want to work here, that creates competition for opportunities. If several major developers want to work with us on a regeneration scheme, they have to compete over what they can offer Brent – social housing, shared ownership, social value and other benefits for the community.

So, I push back against the idea we sometimes hear that being pro-development means being soft on developers. If you’re clear about your priorities, create competition and give people confidence that good schemes can actually get built, you can strengthen the council’s hand.

Shillibeer House on the old bus garage in Alperton is a good example. We worked with the private sector on a development of around 450 homes. Three blocks are private, and the fourth has given us 155 council homes. They look exactly the same as the private homes. People who had spent years in temporary accommodation now have a permanent council home. Some of the people who’ve moved in have made videos sharing their stories and the difference a council home has made to them. We couldn’t have delivered that outcome without being prepared to work in partnership with the private sector.

RB: Labour is now running Brent as a minority administration. How do you maintain that confidence when the council’s political position has changed?

There was inevitably some uncertainty among developers after the election. They wanted to know whether Brent’s political direction had changed. My message to them is very simple: it hasn’t.

We’re still the administration and there’s an enormous amount we continue to do. The Leader, the Cabinet and I are completely aligned about the importance of housing and regeneration, and that gives a clear direction to our officers in the planning department. People often want to come and work here , cut their teeth in the sector in Brent and a lot of them stay a long time, because they have the space to see projects through and make a difference.

But we do need to keep providing that certainty externally – maintaining relationships with developers and Housing Associations, being clear that we want growth and demonstrating that Brent remains somewhere where good development can happen.

Housing has also become more politically contested locally. Opposition parties have campaigned against development of all kinds including social housing, so those of us who believe we need more homes have to be willing to make the argument for them.

I do think attitudes are changing, too. On the planning committee we have had young people come along to speak in favour of housing applications because they wanted the opportunity to find a home in the borough where they were born and raised. The housing crisis is increasingly something people can see in their own families and communities.

RB: How do you make sure Brent is building the right homes to meet all those different kinds of housing need?

You have to manage housing delivery as a portfolio across the borough, rather than judge success by one tenure or the affordable housing percentage on one individual development. Our policy aims for 50% affordable housing across development, with 70% of that total to weighted towards social rent and London Affordable Rent products, as that is our area of greatest need. But that doesn’t mean every individual scheme will deliver exactly 50%. Some will provide less and others can provide 100%. What matters is what we’re securing across the programme as a whole.

So there may be circumstances where a development doesn’t achieve the headline percentage, but what it does provide is more three-bedroom family homes. We have to think about the actual benefit to Brent residents, rather than treating every site as interchangeable.

Sometimes the housing debate gets divided into two camps. There are people who focus on liberalising planning and getting the private sector building more, and others who put the emphasis on delivering more social housing.

I don’t think those ambitions are contradictory. We should make it easier to build more homes, because the fundamental problem is that we have far too few of them. And at the same time, we should be ambitious about delivering social housing and ensuring it remains a permanent and important part of mixed communities. For me, being an activist council means using all the tools and partners available to get the combination of homes our residents actually need.

RB: What could national or London government do to help Brent go further?

If I could make one change to support our social housing ambitions, I would end the Right to Buy in London.

RB editor’s note: The Government took early action to reduce Right to Buy discounts in November 2024. The Social Housing Bill currently going through Parliament would further restrict the Right to Buy, though the Bill stops short of ending the programme in England.

We’re building council housing ourselves. At Church End, for example, we’re delivering 99 new social homes. But when we plan new council housing, we’ve had to make assumptions about how many of those homes could subsequently be lost through Right to Buy.

That matters before a single home has been sold. Council housing requires long-term borrowing and investment. If you know that some of the assets you’re building could subsequently be sold at a discount, that affects the risk, the finances and ultimately how much more housing you can build.

And I don’t think Right to Buy has achieved what it was supposed to achieve in London. It was intended to expand home ownership, but many former council homes have ended up being rented out privately at higher rents or lost to the short lets sector. That means people in Brent have to pay those higher rents, which means they can’t save for a deposit, which means they can’t buy their own homes. Therefore, I believe that in London at least, Right to Buy has completely failed on its own terms. That’s why I’d like to see a London-specific policy, in the same way as Wales has ended it.

There is a more fundamental point too. My grandad lived in the same council flat in Sheffield for his whole life. He had no intention of buying it. Why would he? It was his home for as long as he needed it.

Social housing shouldn’t simply be a residual tenure for somebody who happens to be poor at a particular moment in their life. If somebody moves into a council home when they’re young and struggling, then gets a good job, we shouldn’t suddenly think they earn too much to deserve to live in their home or their community.

Would you like to write for Red Brick? Email rose.grayston@gmail.com to pitch your piece (c.600-900 words)

Categories
Blog Post

How to increase investment in council housing and capitalise on the economic benefits

The Prime Minister has made clear his ambition: to “oversee the biggest council house building programme since the post-war period”. This is a hugely positive step forward for the Government’s housing policy; it marks a generational break with 45 years of housing policy that failed to articulate a clear aim beyond merely maximising overall output – with little regard to affordability for people on low incomes or at risk of homelessness. And, crucially, it will help to capitalise on councils’ knowledge of local housing need, significant land value capture powers, and masterplanning capabilities.  

Yet the decline of council housing was driven not only by housing policy, but by the rise of restrictive fiscal policy that actively constrains government investment in social homes and has pushed Housing Revenue Accounts (HRAs) into existential financial jeopardy. Despite being justified under the guise of ‘fiscal responsibility’, debt-to-GDP spiked sharply during austerity while investment in public assets like social housing collapsed and vital services were cut – demonstrably impoverishing both people and the state.

At the Autumn Budget, to realise its ambitions on council housebuilding, the Government must reconnect political ends with economic means and drive a change in economic consensus that places social housing investment at the centre of national renewal. In an upcoming report on council house building, we argue the Budget marks a clear opportunity for the Government to cancel £31.8bn in HRA debt to unlock councils’ capacity to build, covered in detail here, and do more to bring forward and increase funding – ensuring its fiscal framework supports rather than hinders greater investment in council and social homes.

The financial and economic case for cancelling HRA debt and increasing investment

Modelling commissioned by Shelter and undertaken by Pragmatix sets out an ambitious scenario for the Government to cancel HRA debt and provide the necessary investment to deliver 284,000 social rent homes within a 10-year trajectory – in addition to those already expected to be delivered through the Social and Affordable Homes Programme. Pragmatix estimates that the economic benefits of the policy would outweigh its costs within twenty years, around a decade after the final homes are built. Over the report’s 60-year appraisal period, the modelling estimates a net economic benefit of £141.5 billion, including substantial savings to the public sector from reducing reliance on more expensive forms of housing. Government departments are estimated to save £64.7 billion over the period, including £26.3 billion for the Department for Work and Pensions, while savings to councils from reducing the number of households in temporary accommodation eventually reach £672 million a year.

Cancelling HRA debt is broadly fiscally neutral; the majority of debt is owed to Treasury, meaning it is largely a series of inter-government transfers, involving cancelling debt that the public sector owes to itself.

The fiscal framework should support rather than hinder investment

Within this Parliament, debt cancellation and delivery, as outlined above, is also compliant with the Government’s ‘investment rule’, using around 56% of the current ‘headroom’ as of the OBR’s 2026 spring forecast. While council and social housing is a more-than-worthy use of investment ‘headroom’, this self-imposed restraint on public investment creates artificial trade-offs with other policy areas and reduces the Government’s appetite to increase funding. More flexibility is therefore needed within the fiscal framework to ensure that the long-term economic net benefit of investing in social housing is recognised.

The Government’s fiscal framework disincentivises social housing investment

The narrow and short-term focus of the current fiscal framework discourages social housing investment and hinders the Government’s aim of delivering a council housing revolution. Firstly, the Government’s rolling target (the ‘investment rule’) requires its chosen debt measure to be falling as a share of GDP in the third year of the OBR’s forecast period – but this disregards the longer-term savings and additional revenue social housing generates.

Secondly, the Government’s chosen debt measure – Public Sector Net Financial Liabilities (PSNFL) – fails to value the physical asset created on the Government’s balance sheet when it funds a new social home.

Thirdly, PSNFL creates a two-tier fiscal system that favours social housing delivery through housing associations and for-profit registered providers over public-led social housebuilding from councils and development corporations. Unlike most EU countries that use a general government debt measure, PSNFL includes the entire public sector. It means that our fiscal rules include the debt of our public social housing providers, even though their debts are paid for by rents and other independent income as opposed to taxation or wider government expenditure – i.e. they are classed by the ONS as ‘market producing’.

Finally, because of this public-sector focus in the debt measure, the central government financial asset recorded under PSNFL when investing in council housing (created by loaning money to HRAs via the Public Works Loan Board) is actually netted off by the liability held by the loan recipient (the council or development corporation) in the national accounts. This leaves only the liability on the Government’s balance sheet created from the borrowing it undertook to ‘fund’ the loan. In contrast, liabilities held by private registered providers to pay back loans to central government are excluded from PSNFL, making these loans more fiscally attractive for central government: the asset (the loan) and liability (borrowing to ‘fund’ the loan) held by central government cancel each other out.

The consequences for social and council housebuilding are stark

Rather than seeing good growth and healthy public finances as the outcome of social housing investment, the current framework forces housing policy towards day-to-day spending on housing benefit and expensive temporary accommodation – which flows outwards from the public sector to private landlords. Investment remains far below what is needed:

  • Social and Affordable Homes Programme grant, while welcome, only enables the delivery of 18,000 social rent homes a year on average – we need to deliver 90,000 a year for 10 years to end the housing emergency.
  • Interest rates from the Public Works Loan Board available to HRAs remain far too high with 50-year maturity lending at around 6%.
  • HRAs and public development corporations are excluded from £2.5 billion in 0.1% interest loans recently provided to housing associations and for-profit providers, a distinction that reflects their different treatment within the fiscal framework.

Fiscal reform is needed to support the scaling up of council housing delivery

To deliver its promise of a council housing revolution, the Government must scale up current grant funding and available low-cost finance to much higher levels. In doing so, it must ensure that councils and development corporations, who were the key players of the post-war social housing boom, are empowered to support the Government’s social housing ambition. In an upcoming report later this month, we argue that, if the Government remains committed to not change the current fiscal rules, it should instead exclude HRAs and development corporations from PSNFL. This would finally end central government incentives to limit their borrowing, devolving power to HRAs and development corporations, and support the Government to provide them with the low-cost loans needed to deliver social housing at scale.

Email your councillor today and ask them to add their name to a letter to the chancellor, urging him to knock down the barriers to getting councils social homes again.  https://campaigns.shelter.org.uk/tell-your-cllr-fight-for-social-homes

Would you like to write for Red Brick? Email rose.grayston@gmail.com to pitch your piece (c.600-900 words)

Categories
Blog Post

If Andy Burnham is serious about a council housebuilding revolution, what does he need to know about the self-financing settlement for the HRA? 

I was one of the many council housing finance geeks working with councils to influence the self-financing settlement for Housing Revenue Accounts (HRAs) back in 2012.

It was aimed at making council housing finance more accountable and transparent at the local level as well as more business-like and efficient.  The process of moving from a national subsidy system to individual self-financed HRAs was also designed to make the finances sustainable in the long term and allow for growth and investment. 

It was a hard-won deal between tenants, councils and different governments over a number of years that ended up not delivering on its promise from the outset, only to further suffer from a series of policy and financial setbacks in the years following 2012. These have meant that most councils do not have a sustainable HRA – just 14 years after the original settlement.  The sector is now asking the Government to put things right, but there are many options to look at. 

Why self-financing replaced the ‘tenant tax’

Before 2012, HRA revenue finance was tightly controlled at a national level within the HRA Subsidy System.  The key feature was an annual calculation made to capture surpluses generated by most councils through their rents and redistribute them to others whose rental income did not cover their necessary expenditure. Part of the surpluses also went to the Treasury.

This was dubbed the ‘tenant tax’ by tenant groups who campaigned for change in the years running up to the settlement.  They objected to their rents being used to repair homes at the other end of the country when new homes or improvements could have been made in their areas.  Councils also objected to the lack of control and uncertainty inherent in the annual determinations, which left them with no ability to plan long term or manage maintenance over multi-year projects. 

During earlier years of the subsidy system, the Treasury topped up the pot to ensure that basic management and maintenance could be covered by all councils. But as rents increased and assumed expenditure did not, the overall system went into surplus. By 2008 the vast majority of councils were paying into central government, and the Government was making a surplus on council housing. 

This only increased the arguments for a self-financing deal and could have provided for a more generous and sustainable settlement, had it not been for the financial crash and its impact on wider government finances. 

How a sustainable settlement became unsustainable

The deal that was finally offered to councils by the Coalition Government in 2012 meant most councils had to take on additional debt and did not build in any allowance for investment in new homes. These councils had effectively to buy themselves out of the system to compensate the Treasury for its loss of annual income.  Councils therefore took on debt which the Government calculated would be sustainable for them to hold alongside managing their homes. Collectively, councils took on £8 billion of extra net debt. 

This was not an appealing offer to many councillors or tenants, especially where Housing Revenue Accounts started out debt-free, but ultimately, they agreed it was a price worth paying for a more independent future which would allow them the freedom to make local decisions and plan over the long term. 

Unfortunately, the assumptions underpinning the self-financing deal did not last long –Right to Buy was immediately ‘re-invigorated’ and many more sales were made than assumed, reducing the rental income the 2012 debt calculation was predicated on. 

Rent policy was then changed significantly. Instead of increasing steadily by inflation, rents were reduced by 1% in cash terms each year from 2016 to 2020 taking a significant amount of money out of councils’ budgets.   

Alongside that loss of income have been unforeseen drivers of increased costs; the need for increased building and fire safety work and meeting new decent homes and energy efficiency targets, alongside much higher cost inflation than expected.  Whilst councils were always prepared for some ups and downs, these pressures have pushed some to breaking point. There is simply not enough money in the system to allow council housing to be run properly.

Why debt write-off alone won’t solve the problem

Shelter has recently published further analysis on debt in the HRA by Savills which builds on work they did for CIH in 2024 to look at an updated debt settlement.  Savills conclude that “there is little or no capacity to support the ability for local authorities to contribute meaningfully to the government’s target of 1.5million new homes and therefore to enhance the delivery of social rent homes.” Shelter is therefore calling for the write-off of all HRA debt. 

We agree there is an urgent need for HRA debt to be looked at, but councils’ ability to invest in new homes will still be limited by the needs of their existing homes.  Due to different original rent levels, the type and age of the homes they own and the level of housing need in their areas, each local authority is in a very different position now compared to 2012. London and other inner-city authorities are facing significantly increased costs in dealing with building safety and the need for wider regeneration, whilst others have lost more homes through the Right to Buy and lack the land to replace them.    

A new settlement for a new council housebuilding era

We are therefore calling for the Treasury and MHCLG to be tasked jointly with reviewing these issues to facilitate council house building.  The review should meaningfully engage with councils and tenants as well as sector experts at the earliest opportunity to ensure that key stakeholders concerns and aspirations are fully understood and that lessons from the past are learnt. 

It took almost a decade for councils, tenants and the government to develop and agree the principles for the original self-financing settlement. We urge the new administration to start this work urgently so that councils can be placed back onto a sustainable footing to invest in both existing and new homes.  Tenants have already waited long enough.

Would you like to write for Red Brick? Email rose.grayston@gmail.com to pitch your piece (c.600-900 words)