Categories
Blog Post

A secure home shouldn’t depend on owning one

Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s first conference as Labour leader opened with a promise to young people locked out of the housing market: a new-build home for just a 2.5% deposit, supported by a government-backed equity loan of up to 20% of the property’s value. Your First Home is a more targeted Help to Buy, aimed at first-time buyers who don’t have help with a deposit from the ‘Bank of Mum and Dad’. In many ways, this is an admirable goal, especially given that the National Audit Office found that 3 in 5 of those who accessed the previous version of the scheme could have bought the same home without it.

Demand-side fixes for structural problems in the housing market fundamentally mean public money boosts developer profits by inflating demand for new homes and subsequently the cost that can be charged for each unit. But beyond this, Your First Home raises bigger questions about progressive approaches to housing.

A generation of people are struggling to find secure, affordable housing. Private rental unaffordability is now a national phenomenon, with rents in every region growing between 6% and 9% per year and 1 in 5 private renters reporting cutting back on food to afford housing costs. The average age of renters is increasing, with the numbers of households aged over 55 in the private rental sector growing by 70% over the last decade. The average age of first-time homeowners is also increasing across the country, rising to 34 years old.

The aspiration of homeownership is not one that should be dismissed. For millions of people, the dream of owning a home is about being free from the anxiety of eviction, or an unaffordable rent increase that tacitly serves as one; it’s about painting walls and making a house a home; about staying close to community, or near their childrens’ school. Ultimately, it’s about security, dignity and control. But why is homeownership the primary route to access these?

A more ambitious vision of housing security would expand people’s choices and control over their homes, rather than making it easier for a fortunate minority to climb the property ladder. The Government’s commitment to a council housing revolution is one way to do this.

For decades, millions of people found security and affordability in council homes. Not only is it a more affordable tenure type, but it’s an explicit form of long-term housing that enables people to put down roots. At its peak in the 1950s, Britain was building more than 200,000 council homes a year, a scale the market has never matched, and to higher standards than private builders were required to meet. By 1979, almost a third of households rented from their council.

Right to Buy turned this collective good into a private asset. Since 1980, around two million council homes have been sold off, with 14,275 sold under Right to Buy during 2025–26 – a 90% increase on the previous year. More than 40% of these former council homes are now owned by private landlords. Research by Common Wealth found that Right to Buy has cost the taxpayer £200bn, and councils are increasingly buying-back homes sold off under Right to Buy at inflated costs. In particularly egregious examples, council houses sold off under Right to Buy are being rented back to local authorities as Temporary Accommodation (TA) just months later. In Havering, a home sold for £102,000 has cost the council £350,000 renting it back as TA; in Newham, a home sold for £77,300, has seen the council pay £200,000 in rent. Given that local authority spending on TA has doubled over the last five years to a record £2.9bn, the problem isn’t that the state is failing to spend on housing. It’s that it’s spending a fortune on the most expensive, least secure version of it – paying exorbitant rents to private landlords, rather than building homes that will still house families in decades to come.

Indeed, that the people living in council homes can stay in them for as long as needed, regardless of whether income rises or falls, has always been a central part of the council house offer. The growing argument that social housing subsidises the ‘wrong’ people, as The Economist put it this summer, is not only wrong, but has been tried before. In 2016, a proposal to make higher earning social housing tenants pay market rents to stay in their homes was dropped before taking effect. It deserved to be. Treating council and social housing as a temporary safety net is precisely what residualised the tenure from a mainstream option for a broad mix of people to a last resort concentrated on the poorest and most vulnerable, while also weakening the public support needed to build more.

Burnham has said housing should be treated as an essential service, not a market of winners and losers. Your First Home, however well targeted, helps a few more people become winners. If the Government is serious about ending forty years of neoliberalism, then the biggest council housebuilding programme since the post-war era is a worthy place to start. But it should be equally serious about what made those homes worth building: yes, lower rents, but also the promise that you could stay. Security, dignity and control over your home shouldn’t depend on whether you can raise a deposit, and the true test of a progressive housing policy shouldn’t be how many people it helps onto the ladder, but how many it gives a secure place to call home.

Would you like to write for Red Brick? Email rose.grayston@gmail.com to pitch your piece (c.600-1200 words)

Categories
Blog Post

Your First Home needs an exit strategy

The revival of the equity loan is welcome. But it arrives in a market of 6 per cent mortgages and uncertain prices – not the cheap money that carried Help to Buy – and the Budget must design for that.

Ask a renter what stands between them and owning a home, and the deposit comes near the top of the list. In polling for the Land, Planning and Development Federation this summer, Public First found that 55 per cent of renters name the deposit as a main barrier to buying, almost as many as cite house prices. Among 18 to 24-year-olds, it is the biggest barrier of all. Saving one while paying rent has become, for many, the work of a decade.

Your First Home, announced last month, goes straight at that barrier. First-time buyers in England will be able to buy a new-build home with a 2.5 per cent deposit, with the state lending a further 20 per cent through an equity loan that is interest-free at first. The detail, including income and price caps, arrives with the Budget on 28 October.

The Federation welcomes it. The new-build market needs a lift, the Government itself concedes it faces “challenging headwinds”, and small builders are feeling them most. Homes are built only as fast as they can be sold, so more buyers means more planning permissions turned into front doors. Every little helps, as the strapline goes.

But a home ownership scheme should be judged by how many buyers are still there, and better off, a decade later. On that test, Your First Home faces a far harsher world than its predecessor.

Help to Buy was born in 2013 into a decade of near-zero interest rates. By the end of 2021 the average UK home cost £275,000, more than half as much again as at launch. Buyers built equity quickly, remortgaged cheaply and often cleared the state’s share within five to seven years. Even so, on Homes England’s figures, some 170,000 loans, around 45 per cent of the total, were still outstanding this spring.

Your First Home buyers will have no such wind at their backs. The average five-year fix hit 6 per cent this month, its highest since September 2023, and markets expect Bank Rate to rise, not fall. Gilt yields are at levels last seen in the late 1990s and Savills expects prices to fall this year and recover only slowly.

Now run the maths. A buyer puts down 2.5 per cent, borrows 77.5 per cent and owes the state 20 per cent of the home’s future value. If prices stand still, five years on the household owns little more than its deposit and the mortgage it has paid down. Those five years of owning rather than renting are worth a lot, of course. But when the interest-free period ends, the household must either pay a rising annual fee or clear the loan by refinancing at more than 90 per cent loan-to-value, at today’s rates. If that coincides with the end of a five-year fix, it faces two cliff edges at once.

That is the refinancing risk, and it is the scheme’s real weak point. The deposit gets people in. Refinancing decides whether they can ever move on. None of this means the scheme is wrong, but it must be built for 2026, not 2013. Five choices in the Budget would make the difference.

First, a longer runway and a gentler slope. The interest-free period should outlast a five-year fix, so the two cliff edges never meet, and the fee that follows should rise with inflation, not inflation plus a premium.

Second, set the caps for a family home, not a starter flat. Price and income caps drawn too narrowly will push buyers into two-bedroom homes they will outgrow, leaving them stuck just as the refinancing problem bites. Caps that let two young professionals buy a three-bedroom house in the first place would give families room to grow. They would also bring a broader range of homes into the scheme, helping the whole sector – and SME builders in particular.

Third, let people buy the state out in small steps. Help to Buy required repayments of at least 10 per cent of the home’s value, each with a fresh valuation. Slices of 5 per cent, priced off a desktop valuation, would let households chip away as incomes grow.

Fourth, agree a refinancing route with lenders before launch. Buyers should be able to move to a new fixed rate without first clearing the equity loan.

Fifth, make it work for small builders. A developer contribution is fair, but a flat levy would fall hardest on SME firms, which built four in ten new homes in the 1980s and around one in ten today. A contribution that scales with volume would keep the door open to the builders the government says it wants more of. The scheme should also run for the whole Parliament, so that builders can buy land against it.

The scheme can help builders sell the homes that planning reform makes possible. It cannot make them possible. That depends on a planning system that releases enough land in the right places, grey belt included. Help for buyers and land for builders are two halves of one policy.

Your First Home is welcome. Its success will depend on the detail and how it fits today’s market. It should be measured not by how many keys are handed over in its first year, but by how many of those buyers, a decade on, have built real equity and are able to move on.

Would you like to write for Red Brick? Email rose.grayston@gmail.com to pitch your piece (c.600-1,200 words)

Categories
Blog Post

Your First Home: building more routes into homeownership

Equity loan schemes seem to have a marmite-like quality: people either love them or hate them. The reaction to the recent announcement of a new scheme in England, Your First Home (YFH), saw both offered. In many respects judgement needs to be delayed until we see the detail in the late October Budget, as much turns on how tightly targeted the scheme is (income caps, price caps etc.) and on the charges that will be borne by households and developers.

The legacy of Help to Buy

The announcement was made shortly after the publication of a very favourable assessment of predecessor Help to Buy schemes (HTB ran from 2013 to 2023 in England) highlighting a net present social value of £25 billion based on the uplift in the value of the equity loans (in 2024/25 prices), an increase in new build of 15% and a boost to home ownership. On the downside, it estimated that there were modest price effects in some areas and that the new build premium was edged up, while around half the users of HTB indicated they could have bought a home without it. Broadly the scheme did meet its objectives of boosting the housing and mortgage markets (including levels of home ownership and developer viability after the Global Financial Crisis) but it seems its efficacy diminished over time, not least as the market recovery continued.

The case for bringing back equity loans

In many respects the battleground here is as much about politics as it is economics. YFH is seen by some as a diversion from the Government’s core aim to rebuild the social housing sector – in my mind a necessary but not sufficient focus of policy. However, it must be borne in mind that in the complex world of government accounting, the spend on this scheme will not count as day to day public expenditure as it is a Financial Transaction. Grant for social housing is capital expenditure, whereas an equity loan creates a financial asset: the Government expects to receive money back. This should largely offset the borrowing needed to finance them under its new debt measure, Public Sector Net Financial Liabilities (PSNFL). While this does not eliminate the financial risks, it means the scheme need not compete directly with social housing investment for the same fiscal resources. In that respect and reflecting the continuing concerns about diminished opportunities for younger households (and the wide political impacts that engenders) opting to return to an equity loan scheme makes a lot of sense.

Of course past performance is no guide to the future and because the UK has recorded house price inflation increasing in only nominal terms for some years, and is now seeing some real declines, it is possible that YFH borrowers could see both their 2.5% deposit lost and the government not fully recovering its equity loan. Such concerns must play a part in the thinking about how to target the scheme and what real impact it might have on the market. It could be quite limited. We also have to think about how loans are repaid and what impact that has on the capacity to make a next move. Currently unpublished Hamptons data suggests that HTB buyers have had to borrow more compared to other first time buyers moving to a next home – but for some that includes paying down any outstanding equity loan. Over the last five years FTBs on remortagaging and moving have borrowed on average 50-60% more, whilst HTB buyers doing the same borrowed an average of  50-85% more. These figures suggest that some Help to Buy borrowers have been able to remortgage or move while repaying their equity loans.

Making homeownership accessible to more people

While we are currently seeing high numbers of first-time buyers entering the housing market it should be borne in mind that many of them will be supported by the Bank of Mum and Dad. This has clear distributional impacts and if we are to avoid home ownership becoming ever more exclusive then schemes such as YFH are important part of the armoury, helping those with moderate jobs and credit but having limited savings get access to home ownership. And it should not stop there – we need to see further reform to shared ownership to allow it to properly fulfil its potential (and where at last we are seeing solid evidence to make the case from the Leasehold Advisory Service, Shared Ownership Resources and the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government) and continued reform to mortgage lending rules, where further announcements are expected. Currently, lenders are restricted in the share of mortgages they can offer worth more than 4.5 times the borrower’s annual income. The limit has lagged behind the reality of a housing market where price appreciation has outstripped income growth, and is impacting upon a range of would be purchasers including those with low deposits and the self-employed.

If home ownership is to continue to play a key role in the UK housing system, it is important that effective “ladders” exist between renting and ownership, and this includes access to a suitable stock of housing, access to mortgages and – where necessary – access to help to bridge the gap between aspiration and effective demand.

Your First Home is no panacea, but it could make a valuable contribution.

Would you like to write for Red Brick? Email rose.grayston@gmail.com to pitch your piece (c.600-900 words)

Categories
Blog Post

The Government is finally asking the right question on housing – so it can’t risk providing the wrong answer again with Help to Buy

The Prime Minister couldn’t have been clearer to the Labour Party conference hall: he intends to end our broken housing system. Just as he said on the steps of Downing Street, he remains committed to ending rough sleeping. But he went further and more personal, sharing the legacy of his parent’s decent home in Keble Drive in Old Roan. How that home ensured his family could fulfil the aspirations that led him to that conference hall.

He outlined more policy on building council homes, helping councils access public land, reforming Right to Buy and restoring the quality of our social housing stock. He indicated going further on the Renters’ Rights Act, with new powers to allow councils to acquire rented homes from slum landlords.

It’s worth noting how his policies are now in complete contrast to the Opposition. Ahead of her own party conference, Kemi Badenoch pledged to end the requirement for developers to contribute to affordable housing when building their penthouses. She also committed to removing rules that made those homes easy to keep warm and cool in. As Burnham is showing how Labour can bring hope back, the Tories are embarking on a relentless raid on aspiration.

That said, there was one potential fly in the ointment of the Prime Minister’s vision for housing. He also announced the new Your First Home scheme, explaining it would “reduce the size of the deposit you need.”

On the surface, this seems an inherently sensible policy. Too many young families are stuck in the private rented sector – something which should be a choice has become their only option. Each month they pay their rent which, often, then pays off their landlord’s mortgage. Why not help them into ownership?

But is this scheme a new idea, or is it a reheated programme from the George Osborne era? And if so, how can past mistakes be avoided?

Is this Help to Buy 2.0?

In 2013, Help to Buy constituted £3.5bn of the government’s spending on housing, dwarfing all other measures. Most critically, it arguably contributed to the loss of 260,000 social homes over the following decade by diverting away the funds that would have paid for more social homes.

Evaluations from the IFS and Shelter, have shown the failings of the scheme. The money often helped those ‘almost owning’ at the expense of the ‘almost homeless’. If Help to Buy’s 2013 spending commitment had been invested in social housing it could have resulted in around 35,000 new homes for homeless young people. 

Help to Buy may have been a loan rather than a grant, intended to boomerang back to government coffers in the end, but it still took up most of the Cameron-era housing budget. Worse, as the loan was linked to the house prices, many of the supposed beneficiaries had to pay more for their loan as the scheme inflated their home’s worth without benefiting them. Some defaulted and lost their home.

But didn’t Help to Buy work?

A recent Government-led evaluation of Help to Buy, claimed the policy added value. But it is critical to know what question the paper was answering. It was tasked to see if Help to Buy added value in isolation of other policies. Yes, Help to Buy did subsidise some first time buyers. But that doesn’t make it a more efficient use of limited Government funds than other schemes would have been. When I eat a Mars bar, I take calories on board. It doesn’t mean that was the most healthy or efficient choice for my dinner or my budget.

Building our way to affordability?

Help to Buy made more sense if you look at the challenge the Cameron Government set itself. This Government, like many before it, has made a commitment to increase the raw supply of homes in this country over the kind of genuinely affordable homes needed.

The argument for raw supply has come from think tanks and developers, and think tanks funded by developers. It is a simple one – build more homes, and homes will begin costing less. But it doesn’t follow the logic of supply and demand. Last year, according to Savills, over 200,000 new homes were delivered in England. But there are almost 36 million dwellings in England. What happens to the price of goods when the supply of it is increased by 0.5%? Nothing whatsoever.

Homes don’t work like the iPhone. People rushing out to buy a fancy foldable model may well then put their old phone on Backmarket for thrifty folk to snap up at a discount. That’s not what happens when a Saudi investment company unloads its Mayfair property assets. They are traded off to someone else, holding or increasing their value, and over 170,000 children in England remain without a home.

Is the Government repeating past mistakes?

It’s clear the Labour Government is not suggesting a copy and paste of Help to Buy. Critically, they’re not betting the house on it. As Burnham’s speech made clear, Your First Home sits within an array of progressive policies to fix the Private Rented Sector and grow back our quantity of social homes. The offer will also have more sensible caps on who the offer is for based on their income as well as the price of the home it can be used on.

But this does not mean the scheme is without risk and not in need of careful thought. Taking on a mortgage with only a 2.5% deposit is something first time buyers should consider carefully, particularly in a time of global economic uncertainty and the risk of high inflation. In the end, this scheme’s role must be recognised as limited and specific. It’s clear this Government has the right ambition for solving our housing crisis, and because of that, the Your First Home scheme should always be seen as the support, not the headline, act. 

Would you like to write for Red Brick? Email rose.grayston@gmail.com to pitch your piece (c.600-900 words)

Categories
Blog Post

The Future of Home Buying: Can the government finally fix England’s broken housing transaction system?

After years of half-measures and failed initiatives, the government has again turned its gaze to one of Britain’s most frustrating institutions: the home buying process. It’s a system that is broadly recognised as broken – and one that successive governments have repeatedly promised, and failed, to fix.

The average home move now takes a staggering 205 days from listing to completion. One in three transactions collapses before completion, and £1.5 billion is lost each year through failed sales. These figures represent families stuck in limbo, renters unable to move, and buyers forced to reapply for mortgages as chains collapse around them.

This time, though, there are hopes across industry that the government appears serious. A  consultation on reforms to the system has been launched, and with cross-party consensus that the housing market’s inefficiency acts as a brake on growth, it marks the most significant modernisation attempt in decades. Whether it succeeds may depend less on political will and more on whether the government is ready to embrace the kind of digital innovation that transformed markets abroad.

A long road to reform

For years, the conveyancing process has been defined by paperwork, disconnected systems and inconsistent protocols. Each party – agents, lenders, conveyancers, surveyors, local authorities, and HM Land Registry – operates in its own digital silo, with limited interoperability. The result is predictable delays, duplication, and error embedded in almost every transaction, leaving Britain’s homes stuck as trapped liquidity in the housing market.

The consultation sets out an ambitious vision: a digitally enabled home buying and selling system with consistent use of upfront information, stronger regulation for estate agents, and better consumer protection. It also hints at exploring binding offers and AI-assisted conveyancing, though both remain long-term ambitions rather than immediate reforms.

Ministers argue that reform will “increase transparency, reduce fall-throughs, and improve trust”. It is language that feels familiar. In 2010, the last major reform attempt – the ill-fated Home Information Packs (HIPs) – collapsed under political pressure and technical confusion. Many in the industry fear history could repeat itself.

This time, there’s one crucial difference: the technology now exists to make reforms work.

Proven solutions from abroad?

Australia’s experience offers a compelling glimpse of what the UK could achieve. Over the past decade, the introduction of electronic conveyancing and a digital completion platform has transformed the buying process there.

PEXA is a digital property exchange platform that modernises the process of buying and selling property by allowing solicitors, conveyancers, and lenders to complete property transactions electronically, replacing traditional paper-based systems. Originating in Australia, its UK bespoke platform connects lenders and conveyancers in a secure shared digital environment, improving collaboration, automating financial settlement, and expediting title lodgement.

Through PEXA as the core infrastructure, all parties in a transaction – conveyancers, lenders, and land registries – can transfer funds securely, and validate and register title in real time.

The results are stark. The average settlement in Australia takes five weeks. [CD1] [LM2] [CD3] Settlement fraud has been virtually eliminated, requisitions (manual errors delaying registration) have fallen significantly, and there is consumer confidence in the process.

It is, in short, a working model of what a digital property market can deliver.

In the UK, PEXA has now built a platform specifically for the challenges of the UK market. NatWest is currently implementing PEXA with a view to transacting remortgage transactions by the end of the first half of 2026 and facilitating sale and purchase transactions down the line. The platform is the seventh regulated payment scheme in the Bank of England, and the first built specifically for property transactions. There is growing acknowledgement and excitement that secure, instantaneous completions are now possible on our shores too.

Whether government reforms can align with this kind of digital infrastructure remains uncertain. The consultation makes limited mention of payment and completion reform – a notable omission given that the key moment in a property transaction, when the money moves and title is transferred, remains the moment of greatest risk. Though measures like binding contracts might help prevent fall throughs, the government must ensure it focuses on fixing the act of buying and selling a home, the core transaction, not just the supporting processes.

The fraud problem

It’s a vulnerability that costs consumers and law firms dearly. Fraud is rising across the sector: 65% of law firms have faced cyber incidents and 30% of buyers have experienced property fraud, driven by payment diversion scams, bogus law practices and identity theft.

The structural problem is clear: money and title still move on separate tracks. Funds are manually transferred through generic banking rails, while title changes are lodged with HM Land Registry at some point after completion. In this gap – sometimes hours, sometimes days – the system is at its weakest.

A move towards centralised, regulated digital completion platforms, integrated directly with the banking system, would close that gap. It is a reform that goes beyond convenience; it’s a question of national financial security.

For now, though, fraud prevention appears only lightly referenced in the consultation – folded into broader ambitions around transparency and consumer protection. Many in the industry believe that’s a missed opportunity.

The politics of progress

With successive governments preoccupied with housing supply, conveyancing reform rarely tops the agenda. Yet 42% of buyers report mental health impacts from the stress of moving, and the workforce is under strain too: the number of lawyers practicing in conveyancing in England and Wales has fallen by 15% (from just over 13,000 in Sept 2021 to 11,140 in Jan 2025), reflecting burnout in a system burdened by outdated processes, extra administration, stress and delays.

The challenge, as ever, is sequencing. The financial transaction should sit at the centre of these reforms, not as an afterthought.

For the first time in years, there is genuine momentum. With digital infrastructure now being put in place, a coalition of reformers spanning government, fintech and conveyancing could finally deliver the modernisation that buyers and sellers have long been promised.

For a housing system long stuck in the 20th century, this consultation is a moment of truth.


Categories
Blog Post

Solving the housing crisis requires action at all levels

The UK is in the midst of a housing crisis that isn’t going away anytime soon, with the pandemic only exacerbating this problem and leaving people struggling financially. Whilst we are seeing strong levels of first time buyers get onto the property ladder, simultaneously nearly 1 in 5 (18.7%) of households are occupied by private renters, with a further 16.7% of households occupied by social renters.[1] This is a huge proportion of the population, and whilst we are working to increase access to homeownership, it’s important that those who are currently renting are not left behind.

At MTVH, it is part of our DNA to support people at all levels and provide a quality home. Whilst we offer a dedicated shared ownership through our SO Resi brand, we also support those who are renting. For example, in London we offer London Living Rent which is a form of ‘try before you buy’ and allows Londoners to rent whilst building up savings to buy a home.

But let’s start with shared ownership.

Shared ownership is needed in society, as it provides an affordable opportunity for people to have access to a stable, well-located home. My personal belief in shared ownership is firmly rooted in my own experience – it’s not only how my wife and I were able to buy our first home, but also how my parents were able to get onto the property ladder after moving to the UK in the 1960s. My story is not unique and so many of my colleagues at MTVH have similar anecdotes about how shared ownership has given them the security of homeownership, which we know helps to open other doors to improve overall quality of life.

Our dedicated shared ownership brand SO Resi recently published a research report in conjunction with Cambridge University that looked at the shared ownership market in 2020. Perhaps most significantly, our research showed that since 2015/16, the number of shared ownership completions per year has increased from just 4,084 to 17,021. But it’s important to understand why shared ownership is taking centre stage for young buyers.

A combination of staggering house price growth, increasingly high deposits and a lack of lower loan to value mortgage options has led to aspiring homeowners moving away from the open market and utilising government products such as shared ownership. Whilst the government’s new 95% mortgages may work to address some of these problems, for many people a five per cent deposit on the open market is still out of reach.

Our research also revealed data sets surrounding the proportion of those who staircase each year. There is a misconception that those in shared ownership homes will never staircase, but our research shows that on average between 2-3% of shared owners staircase to 100% ownership each year. Staircasing isn’t possible for all shared owners, but the flexibility of shared ownership means individuals can make the scheme work to suit them – whether that’s living with a 25% ownership or working to increase your shares over a period of time.

Shared ownership has been around for decades, and the government’s plans to amend the product simultaneously presents both opportunities and concerns. Many of those who took part in our research specifically raised concerns around changes that will allow buyers to purchase a minimum 10% share rather than the current minimum of 25%. Housing providers will also be responsible for repairs for 10 years, leading to an increased financial commitment from providers.

There is no denying that these changes are advantageous for the buyer, and will open the doors even wider to homeownership. However, those surveyed believe the shift in responsibility of repairs will reduce the supply of homes that they are able to build. If the level of affordable homes available drops, this will worsen our current housing crisis and plunge more people into difficult situations when it comes to finding a home.

We know that a good home and environment are key in ensuring that everyone has the chance to live well. But homeownership isn’t possible for everyone – and whilst shared ownership increases access, there are still those who rely long-term on renting, whether privately or through a social housing provider.

To solve the housing crisis, we need to offer solutions that deal with different challenges, which vary as people need homes to rent and to buy. Instead of pitting one tenure against another, we need to collaborate and support those who do depend on the rented sector. Rent prices are rising and this is leaving a generation of people locked in paying high rent prices with no possibility of saving, either for a house deposit or to improve their quality of life.

Long-term, we need some clarity on solving the housing crisis as simply launching temporary schemes isn’t enough anymore – we need real policies that tackle the problems faced by young people today to ensure they can continue to get onto the property ladder at an affordable price in their preferred area.

In the current economic climate, shared ownership demonstrates its importance by supporting people to grow and start their families, put down roots and enjoy the benefits of homeownership without having to find the astronomical deposits required to buy on the open market. Like any product, shared ownership isn’t perfect, nor is it the single solution to the housing crisis, but it is an incredibly important offering that bridges the gap between renting and full ownership.

<strong><span class="has-inline-color has-accent-color">Kush Rawal</span></strong>
Kush Rawal

Kush is the Director of Residential Investment at Metropolitan Thames Valley Housing


[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/286444/england-number-of-private-rented-households/

Categories
Blog Post

Shared Ownership: why we deserve far greater transparency

Glossy ads present a rosy picture of shared ownership. But some first-time buyers are discovering the reality doesn’t live up to the rhetoric. Why are shared owners demanding greater transparency from housing associations and the National Housing Federation? This article breaks down some home truths about shared ownership, and what one housing campaigner is doing about it.

Shared ownership isn’t shared and it isn’t ownership. It’s arguable to what degree it constitutes affordable housing. Yet housing associations market this complex tenure with the same degree of levity with which a company might sell, say, comic books or whoopee cushions. The National Housing Federation (Nat Fed) marketing campaign promotes shared ownership schemes with slogans including: ‘Painting every wall luminous green’ and ‘Cooking in your pants on Sundays’.

My younger self would have enjoyed the jocular tone of Nat Fed advertising. My older self thinks the campaign does home buyers a great dis-service by failing to live up to laudable claims of ‘myth busting’ and ‘explaining what shared ownership means’. Taking out a mortgage could be one of the most expensive decisions first-time buyers will ever make. And, if they get it wrong, the consequences can be catastrophic.

An advertorial published during Shared Ownership Week 2020 included a quote from first-time buyer, Laura: “I think a lot of people don’t understand it, they think there’s a catch. There isn’t.” And there’s the problem in a nutshell… It’s perhaps a moot point exactly what constitutes a ‘catch’ but there’s no shortage of possibilities.

For a start, shared owners are often surprised to discover they don’t ‘own’ their home in any meaningful sense. The ‘part buy, part rent’ slogan is widely used in promoting shared ownership. But legal experts suggest that such terminology is potentially misleading as it misrepresents the legal form of the tenure. One law firm, Walker Morris (in a 2017 article ‘Shared Ownership: Risks and Rewards for Lenders’) say: ‘It is incorrect, and therefore misleading and potentially an offence in contravention of the Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations (2008) for housing associations, landlords, developers or lenders to advertise or refer to shared ownership schemes as ‘part buy, part rent’, or indeed by using any other terminology or slogan which suggests that the customer purchases anything other than an assured tenancy leasehold interest at any time prior to the 100% staircasing stage’.

The Nat Fed campaign appears to confuse a marketing strategy (defining ‘it’s yours’ as ‘not sharing’) with the legal reality (it’s not ‘yours’ and there are therefore risks of forfeiture, possession, and loss of or reduction in equity).

Shared ownership isn’t even that good an investment. The Homes England model contract specified a minimum lease length of 99 years for flats up until 2016, and 125 years thereafter. Shared owners have been shocked to discover a need for expensive lease extensions with no benefit other than to maintain the market value of their home. And, of course, some simply can’t afford to do so, and find themselves in possession of a devaluing asset. The London Mayor recently addressed this issue by unveiling a plan to ensure all shared ownership homes built in the capital as part of the new Affordable Homes Programme are sold with a 999-year lease as standard. But this doesn’t address problems faced outside London and also by legacy owners, many stranded with an increasingly unsuitable and undesirable housing product.

It gets worse. Shared owners have no statutory right to lease extension unless they’ve staircased to 100%. I contacted Mike Shone, Homes England’s Monitoring and Reporting Manager, in 2019 to ask what percentage of shared owners achieve full staircasing. The response: ‘Unfortunately this is not something that is recorded by Homes England or the Regulator of Social Housing’. But Parliamentary Research briefing CBP-8828 reports: ‘The increasing costs of shared ownership have made it more challenging for households to progress to full ownership. Around 4,000 households staircased to 100% ownership in 2018/19, equivalent to 2.3% of all shared-equity homes owned by housing associations’.

What about much vaunted affordability claims? These appear reliant on comparison with private rental or open market purchases over a relatively short timescale. They don’t factor in whole life cycle costs such as lease extension; rents that increase annually regardless of whether average market rents are increasing, static, or even declining; and full 100% liability for service and management charges regardless of the % share purchased. (Fire safety remediation costs are too complex to go into here but are self-evidently a source of huge emotional and financial distress for affected shared owners).

Housing sector professionals appear to believe that lawyers should provide information on such issues. Wanda Goldvag, chair of the Leasehold Advisory Service (LEASE), interviewed on Radio 4’s consumer affairs programme You and Yours in January 2019 said: “lawyers have an absolute duty to explain complex clauses to people”.

But it’s hard to understand such reliance on lawyers. Research funded by the Leverhulme Trust (Exploring experiences of shared ownership, 2015) found that: ‘Modern conveyancing practice is not equipped to provide information to buyers about the specifics of shared ownership leases. […] That increases the onus on providers to provide relevant, simple and clear information to buyers’.

Shared ownership is pitched as the ‘affordable’ route into housing. Marketing rhetoric implies that ALL buyers benefit from shared ownership as a ‘step onto the housing ladder’. But this is over-simplistic and fails to recognise that the wider housing market creates both winners and losers.

Moreover, a rapidly rising property market will benefit buyers who interpret ‘a step onto the housing ladder’ as obtaining a first property as an investment generating a gain to help buy their next property, but will disadvantage buyers who interpret it as an opportunity to purchase their forever home in staircasing instalments (the original intention of the scheme per the 1979 Conservative election manifesto). And the converse is equally true.

Whilst risks and opportunities arising from property markets are clearly not restricted to first-time buyers purchasing shared ownership homes, this demographic is particularly vulnerable to financial difficulties and poor outcomes arising from inadequate information and advice.

Housing associations have a dilemma; too much transparency could compromise achievement of sales targets. It’s pragmatic to assume housing associations will continue to place emphasis on short-term benefits to shift units. And, unless there are fundamental changes to the shared ownership model, many shared owners will continue to discover that shared ownership isn’t anywhere near as affordable as those glossy ads suggest.

Could the shared ownership model be improved? Could it be made more affordable? To some degree perhaps… A sector-wide commitment to cease taking advantage of the 2019 Zucconi precedent (a discretionary change in the method for calculating leasehold extension premiums which creates a windfall for housing associations, but pushes lease extension even further out of reach for many shared owners) would help some. Widespread adoption of the London Mayor’s proposal for 999-year leases as standard would render lease extension costs obsolete (except for increasingly disadvantaged legacy owners, of course!).

But here’s the rub… housing associations’ overall funding model has historically depended in part on profits arising from shared ownership schemes (for example, the receipts from staircasing shares sold at current market value rather than original market value) to generate cross-subsidy for social rented homes. So the financial interests of individual shared owners are directly in conflict with the wider objectives of housing associations. Shared owners are discovering they are, in many respects, the benefactors of affordable housing rather than the recipients they thought they were. It’s complicated!

If I had to choose one key policy reform…? “To stop using the term affordable for housing that isn’t” (a phrase I’ve stolen from Tom Murtha). To stop using the term ‘shared’ for housing that isn’t. And to stop using the term ‘ownership’ for housing that isn’t. Though that may not happen anytime soon. First-time buyers, shared owners and leaseholders deserve better. Which is why I’ve created a Crowdfunder project to raise funds for an independent shared ownership website with comprehensive information, analysis, and signposting to sources of professional expertise and advice. The Crowdfunder ends at 2.52pm on 9th February 2021.

Click here: https://www.crowdfunder.co.uk/shared-ownership-resources

<strong><span class="has-inline-color has-accent-color">Sue Phillips</span></strong>
Sue Phillips

Sue Phillips is an accountant (ACCA) who spent much of her career working in the not-for-profit sector. She is now semi-retired. She says she never expected to become a housing campaigner! 

She purchased her own flat via a shared ownership scheme in 1999, staircased to 100% in 2013, and completed a lease extension in 2020.

Her own experience of shared ownership led her to start campaigning in 2019, with a particular focus on greater transparency on potential long-term costs and risks of shared ownership. She campaigns under the moniker Shared Ownership Resources.