Categories
Blog Post

Public land for public good: making room for community-led housing

Housing is top of the agenda again and so much of Andy Burnham’s speech to Labour Party Conference was music to my ears. Getting councils building again, eradicating rough sleeping, a Prime Minister who recognises how having a decent house unlocked opportunities for his own family. Far too often, the debate around housing has been reduced to bricks and mortar. How many units can we deliver and how quickly? But we mustn’t lose sight of the end goal – a home where people can live safe and securely, and communities in which people are supported to thrive.

More than bricks and mortar

During my time as a local councillor and Cabinet Member for New Homes in Southwark, I saw some fantastic examples of people living together in community. On existing council estates where Tenants & Residents’ Associations were not only providing excellent representation on issues like housing repairs, but were running community centres, bringing people together for festivals, and greening their estates. On the Rockingham Estate in South London, part of the ward that I represented, volunteers have turned a corner of SE1 (central London) into a biodiversity haven, designated as a Site of Importance for Nature Conservation and even growing bananas together!

One new development in Bermondsey which has been intentionally designed to inspire community and combat loneliness is the award-winning Appleby Blue Almshouse, run by the United St Saviour’s Charity. It’s not just the oak panelling that makes it special, but the inclusion of residential walkways, an enormous space which often hosts lunches and other events, a community kitchen and beautiful internal courtyard. The research team there have published evidence showing that living in an almshouse can boost life expectancy by 2.5 years.

At a time of deepening polarisation and immense housing need, the design of homes and communities matters more than ever and where the public sector owns land, there are the most options. Whether it’s the new council housing that Andy Burnham is promising, or new dedicated homes for keyworkers, public land can be used to deliver public good. Call that Manchesterism if you like but it’s also what we did in Southwark to deliver Appleby Blue. A charity-led scheme but built on the site of a disused care home owned by Southwark. There is so much pressure on hard-pressed local authorities to dispose of their land on the private market for a capital receipt, but in doing so, this kind of creativity and public good is what you forgo.

Speaking at a Co-operative Party event earlier this year launching their pamphlet, Yes in My Backyard, Angela Rayner threw her weight behind community-led housing and a new co-operative housing tenure. This sector is one which I have been increasingly interested in, and it remains relatively small in the UK compared with our European neighbours. New initiatives like Collective Ownership have the potential to scale up community-led acquisitions, but some schemes also need public land and a bit of state support to get off the ground.

Following the successful delivery of Community Land Trusts (CLTs) in Tower Hamlets and Lewisham, I was working as a Cabinet Member to deliver Southwark’s first CLT in Peckham on council-owned land. This has been progressing slowly, but now, like many other schemes which have a similar model of tenure (discounted sales values which are permanently affordable, linked in perpetuity to average local incomes), there is no grant funding available to make it happen in this form. This model has been excluded from the £39bn Social & Affordable Homes Programme and as yet no replacement or amended Community Housing Fund has been agreed.

Ambition needs funding and political backing

There are challenges across the country for co-operative and community led housing which demonstrate the need for much stronger political support. The immensely saddening dispute between GreenSquare Accord Housing Association and Stirchley Cooperative Development highlights the risks around private partnership, even in this case with a not-for-profit. Another London CLT scheme, which would have provided 41 affordable homes on Cable Street in East London, is now at risk due to a change of view from Transport for London, who own the land. In Yorkshire and the North-East, the will is certainly there and a number of community organisations have recently come together to launch The Northern Way, building on their years of experience bringing empty homes back into use, supporting vulnerable people back into employment and revitalising neighbourhoods that have often felt neglected. But without anything akin to the former Empty Homes Community Grants Programme, the resources just aren’t there to deliver at scale, despite the model ticking multiple boxes: social housing, employment and skills, retrofit, and neighbourhood renewal.

Harnessing the enthusiasm, experience and existing pipeline of these community-led organisations would be a quick win for the new administration, led by our first ever Labour & Cooperative Prime Minister. It is immensely encouraging that housing is such a significant priority for Andy Burnham. His leadership across Greater Manchester on initiatives like Housing First and bringing Empty Homes back into use is now being translated into national policy. That points the way to a more rounded housing policy, focused on using public land and investment. My hope is that the potential for partnering with community groups is now fully realised and integral to this renewed vision to deliver on decent homes and supportive communities for all.

Helen Dennis is a former councillor and Southwark Council Cabinet Member for New Homes and Sustainable Development. She is currently an Associate Fellow at the New Economics Foundation and a board member of London Community Land Trust. She writes here in a personal capacity.

Would you like to write for Red Brick? Email rose.grayston@gmail.com to pitch your piece (c.600-1,200 words)

Categories
Blog Post

England’s Leasehold Reforms Risk Harming Community Land Trusts

Leasehold is the legal mechanism that makes the Community Land Trust model work. Without an exemption for CLTs, the draft Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill risks unintentionally undermining one of the few proven models for permanently affordable, community-controlled land and housing.

In the slow march to end feudal property arrangements since 2017, community-led and cooperative models have been largely overlooked. That’s a mistake, as these models could better achieve some of the Government’s aims.

Governments have been consulting and legislating on this since at least 2017. The Law Commission undertook a major study on leasehold from 2018 to 2020, and the Competition and Markets Authority looked at private estate management in 2023 and 2024.

The reform aims are right – to ban “feudal” arrangements in which homeowners are subject to unaccountable gouging by third-party landlords and managing agents.

But the Government’s solutions are narrow.

In its draft Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill, the Government wants to replace leasehold with commonhold for blocks of flats. Separate consultations propose moving to resident management companies (RMCs) for estates. Both hand ownership and control back to homeowners. It sounds good, but there are other models that are also resident-controlled and which should be considered.

A better model for democratic local stewardship

Community Land Trusts (CLTs) are already taking ownership of, and managing, blocks of flats and estates. Like commonhold they are resident-controlled and owned, and their statutory definition goes further to ensure they must be non-profit and act for the wellbeing of the community. They decommodify land and buildings in a co-operative structure.

But unlike commonhold and RMCs, their membership includes the whole local community in the neighbourhood, not just the homeowners in the block. Renters can have equal power and voice as owners. CLTs can take ownership of multiple developments across a neighbourhood, instead of setting up dozens of tiny companies and boards, one for each block of flats or new estate.

CLTs balance the interests of current occupants and future generations, ensuring that current occupants pay fair fees and that assets are looked after, while also protecting affordable homes and community assets from carpetbagging. They enable communities to act as wise stewards of their place. Many devolve day-to-day management of the homes and communal spaces to occupants, sometimes leasing them to resident associations or companies, while acting as a steward that can step in to help.

CLTs also have purposes broader than simply maintaining assets. They almost always leverage their ownership of homes and community facilities to proactively develop more, contributing to the Government’s growth and housing agendas. This in turn helps to attract more directors, make them more financially sustainable, and furthers the interests of the wider local community.

The benefit of this model over RMCs became very apparent in the CLT Network’s work on a major Ofwat-funded innovation project looking at ‘water smart communities’. We need to build more water-efficient homes with site-wide rainwater harvesting and flood mitigation. But it would be a tall order to ask small site-by-site RMCs to take responsibility for managing these complex assets, as well as the relationships with the Highways Authority, water companies and other stakeholders. It would be much more viable to do this at a town or neighbourhood scale, through adoption of potentially dozens of developments by a single local authority or CLT.

None of this is to say that commonhold and resident management companies are bad models. They’re just not the only resident-controlled model available, and have risks.

Why Community Land Trusts depend on leasehold

But the Government has largely ignored the CLT alternative. In its Draft Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill risks ruling them out. Leasehold is the legal mechanism that makes the CLT model work. By retaining the freehold of the land and granting long leases over individual homes and other assets, CLTs separate land value from building value and hold that land in common ownership for the long term. That legal separation is what enables the CLT to lock in affordability, prevent speculative windfalls, and steward assets for future generations.

Take two models common in the USA, There, CLTs buy the freehold of land which they lease to condominium associations (like commonhold associations), enabling occupants to self-manage under their stewardship. They also often buy flats in condominium blocks built by others, selling or renting them as permanently affordable homes. The homeowners and renters can all join the CLT, and a third of board places are reserved for them. Commonhold and CLTs could co-exist.

Ministers should protect CLTs in the Bill

In the two acts of legislation on leasehold reform to date, previous governments have recognised the value of the CLT model and enabled it by exception. CLTs have been exempted from the ban on leasehold houses and residential ground rents. But the draft Bill currently fails to carry this forward and would not permit the two co-existence models common in the USA.

The Government’s consultation on reducing the prevalence of private estate management arrangements similarly focuses on RMCs as a solution and gives little attention to community models like CLTs, though officials have shown interest.

The opportunity here goes wider than ending the feudal leasehold and estate management practices.

The Government is wrestling with the right way to help communities take back control. With the Pride in Place neighbourhood boards, the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill’s unspecified neighbourhood governance arrangements, and now with commonhold and RMCs, the Government risks creating a disjointed patchwork of community voice and control. At the neighbourhood level, communities struggle to stitch these together into something like a coherent approach.

Models like the Community Land Trust offer one solution, creating a general-purpose community stewardship body with a statutory footing that can stitch together new development, regeneration funding, saving existing assets, etc. It would embed democratic, accountable resident control across these priorities with a consistent, understood and robust model. Ministers should look again at a co-operative solution that communities themselves are championing.

Would you like to write for Red Brick? Email rose.grayston@gmail.com to pitch your piece (c.600-900 words)