Categories
Blog Post

Who is devolution really giving power to?

We have entered a new era in British governance, with devolution moving from a long-term ambition to the defining mission of government.

The promise is simple. Re-wire the state and move power away from Westminster and into the hands of regional leaders, bringing decision-making closer to the communities it affects.

But if power is moving closer to communities, who is it actually being devolved to?

The lessons we can’t afford to forget

For more than 35 years, Tpas has championed one simple principle – that housing works better when the residents affected by decisions help shape them. That belief has guided our work with residents, landlords, regulators and government, and it has helped drive significant change across the housing sector.

Grenfell forced the industry to confront an uncomfortable reality, when residents aren’t heard, the consequences can be devastating.

The reforms that followed, including stronger Consumer Standards, Tenant Satisfaction Measures, Awaab’s Law and greater transparency and accountability, recognised a simple truth: lived experience is not an optional extra. It is fundamental to good governance.

Over the coming months and years, we can expect to see powers over housing and communities increasingly move into combined authorities and local government.

This is welcome news, but there is a real risk that community voices cannot keep pace. Too often, engagement stops at the landlord level while the biggest decisions about investment, regeneration and place are made elsewhere.

We cannot afford to create a new generation of institutions that are any further removed from the people they serve than the ones they replace.

The next challenge for devolution

Our new policy paper, From Devolution to Participation, argues that resident participation must become part of the foundations of England’s devolved housing system, rather than an afterthought once decisions have already been made.

The report is not calling for more consultation for consultation’s sake. It sets out practical ways to give residents meaningful influence over the decisions being made at regional level.

That means creating resident advisory structures with a direct route into Combined Authority housing teams; ensuring evidence from tenant scrutiny, complaints and Tenant Satisfaction Measures shapes regional strategy and investment; supporting tenant-led organisations to participate on an equal footing; and requiring decision-makers to show residents what changed as a result of their involvement.

A once-in-a-generation opportunity

None of this requires starting from scratch. Nor will it be expensive. The foundations are already in place. The housing sector already has decades of experience, evidence and established structures to draw on.

We have seen from areas where devolution is already well established, such as the West Midlands Combined Authority and via the Good Landlord Charter in Greater Manchester, mayors and leaders are taking tenant voice seriously.

The task now is to formalise approaches and connect  expertise on tenant engagement to more regional bodies making increasingly significant decisions about homes, investment and place.

Every day, tenants contribute insight through panels, complaints and local forums. The challenge is not necessarily about listening, it is about acting on those voices so they influence the strategic decisions shaping housing investment that will be led by mayors.

If this Government is serious about democratic renewal, housing has the opportunity to become the blueprint for how communities shape regional government.

The political foundations are now in place. Andy Burnham has spoken about moving power closer to people, while Angela Rayner has long championed stronger communities and greater local influence.

How can we judge success?

As the Government begins the process of redesigning how England is governed, it has a unique opportunity to ensure community participation is built into that new system from the very beginning.

The success of devolution won’t be measured by how many powers leave Westminster.

Instead, it will be measured by whether the people those powers are meant to serve have a genuine seat at the table.

The housing sector has already learned, through both success and tragic experience, that better decisions are made when residents are listened to. Let’s not build a new system of regional government only to repeat the mistakes of the old one.

There will be plenty of people who are asking who devolution is really giving power to. The answer should be simple – the people whose lives those decisions shape every day.

If power is moving out of Westminster, resident voice must move with it.

Would you like to write for Red Brick? Email rose.grayston@gmail.com to pitch your piece (c.600-900 words)

Categories
Blog Post

Right to transfer

Rose Grayston

Rose is editor of Red Brick. She has worked to develop and win support for solutions to the UK’s housing crisis as Expert Adviser to Matthew Pennycook, Minister for Housing and Planning, as a Labour activist and founding member of Open Labour, and through roles at Shelter, the New Economics Foundation and Generation Rent.

<strong><span class="has-inline-color has-accent-color">Steve Hilditch</span></strong>
Steve Hilditch

Founder of Red Brick. Former Head of Policy for Shelter. Select Committee Advisor for Housing and Homelessness. Drafted the first London Mayor’s Housing Strategy under Ken Livingstone. Steve sits on the Editorial Panel of Red Brick.

Attracting virtually no comment at the time it was passed, an obscure clause in Labour’s 2008 Housing and Regeneration Act could offer council tenants a unique but controversial way of owning and running their own homes.

Section 34A, as it is known, requires a local authority to co-operate with a formal notice from a tenant group to transfer ownership of council homes and estates to them.  The government has decided to press forward with making regulations under the section and has branded it the right to transfer.  A draft is expected in February.

As a policy, S34A is a direct descendant of the Tenants Choice legislation that was introduced by the Conservatives in 1988.  The political belief at the time was that tenants would rise up to take control of their housing from Labour councils who ran their housing badly.  In practice, and famously, it was used by Walterton & Elgin Community Homes (WECH) to take over their estates when Westminster Council, led by Shirley Porter, tried to sell them to developers.  As it didn’t lead to the hoped-for tenants’ revolt in Labour areas, and caused embarrassment in Westminster, it was repealed in the mid 1990s. 

WECH is still going strong, a leading example of tenant control working in practice.  Based on its experiences, the organisation has become a strong advocate of the principle that genuine empowerment through community ownership and control can lead to measureable improvements in happiness and wellbeing.

The right to transfer is seen by the ConDems as furthering both Localism and the Big Society.  So we have Labour legislation and ConDem implementation, does this mean there is a consensus that the right to transfer is a good thing?  The left has often been divided on the issues of tenant control and, in particular, tenant ownership.  The co-operative and mutual traditions run deep, but there has often been hostility to moving ownership out of the public sector and away from traditional democratic control.  Is transfer from a council to collective tenant ownership and control ‘privatisation’ or a different form of socialised ownership?  I go for the latter as long as the model does not allow for private gain (as some earlier co-ownership models did) and the homes are properly used to meet housing need.

There are of course dangers to negotiate.  If tenants wish to transfer part of a local authority’s stock to their ownership, coming out of the housing revenue account is hugely complex and has risks for both sides.  Other major issues to deal with include the viability of the new tenant organisation and the long-term relationship with the parent authority over issues like allocations and future development. 

The right to transfer will also cause bigger political divisions in the Conservative Party.  In Hammersmith and Fulham, normally the incubator of Tory housing policy, tenants on estates threatened by demolition as part of the huge Earls Court redevelopment have already served notice that they want to take over their estates, potentially scuppering the council’s plans to reduce the amount of social housing in the borough.  Will the government be willing to effectively overrule the Prime Minister’s favourite council to pursue its policy?

Given the need for the Labour Party to develop a new stance on housing, my own view is that Ed Miliband and the housing front bench should support tenants interested in using this new power. 

PS – In legislative technicalities, S296 of the Housing & Regeneration Act 2008 introduced a new Section 34A to the 1985 Housing Act.