Categories
Blog Post

Your First Home needs an exit strategy

The revival of the equity loan is welcome. But it arrives in a market of 6 per cent mortgages and uncertain prices – not the cheap money that carried Help to Buy – and the Budget must design for that.

Ask a renter what stands between them and owning a home, and the deposit comes near the top of the list. In polling for the Land, Planning and Development Federation this summer, Public First found that 55 per cent of renters name the deposit as a main barrier to buying, almost as many as cite house prices. Among 18 to 24-year-olds, it is the biggest barrier of all. Saving one while paying rent has become, for many, the work of a decade.

Your First Home, announced last month, goes straight at that barrier. First-time buyers in England will be able to buy a new-build home with a 2.5 per cent deposit, with the state lending a further 20 per cent through an equity loan that is interest-free at first. The detail, including income and price caps, arrives with the Budget on 28 October.

The Federation welcomes it. The new-build market needs a lift, the Government itself concedes it faces “challenging headwinds”, and small builders are feeling them most. Homes are built only as fast as they can be sold, so more buyers means more planning permissions turned into front doors. Every little helps, as the strapline goes.

But a home ownership scheme should be judged by how many buyers are still there, and better off, a decade later. On that test, Your First Home faces a far harsher world than its predecessor.

Help to Buy was born in 2013 into a decade of near-zero interest rates. By the end of 2021 the average UK home cost £275,000, more than half as much again as at launch. Buyers built equity quickly, remortgaged cheaply and often cleared the state’s share within five to seven years. Even so, on Homes England’s figures, some 170,000 loans, around 45 per cent of the total, were still outstanding this spring.

Your First Home buyers will have no such wind at their backs. The average five-year fix hit 6 per cent this month, its highest since September 2023, and markets expect Bank Rate to rise, not fall. Gilt yields are at levels last seen in the late 1990s and Savills expects prices to fall this year and recover only slowly.

Now run the maths. A buyer puts down 2.5 per cent, borrows 77.5 per cent and owes the state 20 per cent of the home’s future value. If prices stand still, five years on the household owns little more than its deposit and the mortgage it has paid down. Those five years of owning rather than renting are worth a lot, of course. But when the interest-free period ends, the household must either pay a rising annual fee or clear the loan by refinancing at more than 90 per cent loan-to-value, at today’s rates. If that coincides with the end of a five-year fix, it faces two cliff edges at once.

That is the refinancing risk, and it is the scheme’s real weak point. The deposit gets people in. Refinancing decides whether they can ever move on. None of this means the scheme is wrong, but it must be built for 2026, not 2013. Five choices in the Budget would make the difference.

First, a longer runway and a gentler slope. The interest-free period should outlast a five-year fix, so the two cliff edges never meet, and the fee that follows should rise with inflation, not inflation plus a premium.

Second, set the caps for a family home, not a starter flat. Price and income caps drawn too narrowly will push buyers into two-bedroom homes they will outgrow, leaving them stuck just as the refinancing problem bites. Caps that let two young professionals buy a three-bedroom house in the first place would give families room to grow. They would also bring a broader range of homes into the scheme, helping the whole sector – and SME builders in particular.

Third, let people buy the state out in small steps. Help to Buy required repayments of at least 10 per cent of the home’s value, each with a fresh valuation. Slices of 5 per cent, priced off a desktop valuation, would let households chip away as incomes grow.

Fourth, agree a refinancing route with lenders before launch. Buyers should be able to move to a new fixed rate without first clearing the equity loan.

Fifth, make it work for small builders. A developer contribution is fair, but a flat levy would fall hardest on SME firms, which built four in ten new homes in the 1980s and around one in ten today. A contribution that scales with volume would keep the door open to the builders the government says it wants more of. The scheme should also run for the whole Parliament, so that builders can buy land against it.

The scheme can help builders sell the homes that planning reform makes possible. It cannot make them possible. That depends on a planning system that releases enough land in the right places, grey belt included. Help for buyers and land for builders are two halves of one policy.

Your First Home is welcome. Its success will depend on the detail and how it fits today’s market. It should be measured not by how many keys are handed over in its first year, but by how many of those buyers, a decade on, have built real equity and are able to move on.

Would you like to write for Red Brick? Email rose.grayston@gmail.com to pitch your piece (c.600-900 words)